A lawyer who accused an Alabama coal company of human-rights abuses in Colombia was hit with a $256 million jury verdict amid evidence plaintiff witnesses were paid for their testimony and a competing mining firm had an interest in the case.
Drummond Co. has been fighting attorney Terrence Collingsworth for more than a decade over claims it paid militia to guard its lucrative coal mine in Colombia. Collingsworth was successful in suing Chiquita over similar claims but now faces a huge verdict thanks to emails and other documents Drummond’s lawyers uncovered during years of litigation. Another law firm active in human-rights lawsuits, Conrad & Scherer, settled on the eve of trial.
kAmkDA2?m%96 >@?F>6?E2= G6C5:4E C6AC6D6?ED 2?@E96C G:4E@CJ 3J 4@>A2?:6D 7:89E:?8 324< :? 4@FCE 282:?DE ?@?AC@7:E 24E:G:DE 8C@FAD E92E FD6 =:E:82E:@? 2?5 AF3=:4:EJ 42>A2:8?D E@ ECJ E@ 52>286 E96:C 3FD:?6DD] {2DE J62C[ 2 ;FCJ :? @C56C65 vC66?A6246 x?E6C?2E:@?2= E@ A2Jk^DA2?m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=682=?6HD=:?6]4@>^8C66?A6246\@C56C65\E@\A2J\6?6C8J\EC2?D76C\eee\g\>:==:@?\:?\52>286D^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmkDA2?mSeef >:==:@? E@ t?6C8J %C2?D76Ck^DA2?mk^2m kDA2?m7@C :ED C@=6 :? G:@=6?E AC@E6DED E92E 5:DCFAE65 4@?DECF4E:@? @7 E96 s2<@E2 p446DD A:A6=:?6] pEE@C?6J $E6G6? s@?K:86Ck^DA2?m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=682=?6HD=:?6]4@>^5\4\DFDA6?5D\=2HJ6C\DE6G6?\5@?K:86C\27E6C\7C2F5\CF=:?8\:?\>F=E:3:==:@?\5@==2C\7:89E\282:?DE\496GC@?^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmkDA2?m=@DE 9:D =2H =:46?D6k^DA2?mk^2m kDA2?m:? (2D9:?8E@? s]r] 27E6C r96GC@? H@? 2 42D6 244FD:?8 9:> @7 @3E2:?:?8 2 Sh]d 3:==:@? G6C5:4E :? t4F25@C E9C@F89 7C2F5]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mr@==:?8DH@CE9[ E96 49:67 @7 x?E6C?2E:@?2= #:89ED p4E:G:DED[ DF65 sCF>>@?5 C6A62E65=J @G6C 4=2:>D :E H2D C6DA@?D:3=6 7@C E96 562E9D @7 F?:@? =6256CD 2?5 @E96CD 2E E96 92?5D @7 A2C2>:=:E2CJ 8C@FAD 24E:G6 5FC:?8 r@=@>3:2’D 4:G:= H2C] sCF>>@?5 56?:65 E96 2==682E:@?D 2?5 4@F?E6CDF65 r@==:?8DH@CE9[ 244FD:?8 9:> @7 723C:42E:?8 4=2:>D E@ 6IE@CE 2 S` 3:==:@? D6EE=6>6?E]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mp7E6C =62C?:?8 E92E r@==:?8DH@CE9 925 A2:5 E9C66 H:E?6DD6D :? r@=@>3:2 367@C6 E96J DF3>:EE65 564=2C2E:@?D E@ DFAA@CE 9:D 4=2:>D[ sCF>>@?5 4@?G:?465 2 7656C2= ;F586 :? p=232>2 E@ 2==@H 7FCE96C 5:D4@G6CJ E92E F?62CE965 6>2:=D[ E6IE >6DD286D 2?5 @E96C 5@4F>6?ED 56E2:=:?8 E6?D @7 E9@FD2?5D @7 5@==2CD :? A2J>6?ED E@ H:E?6DD6D]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?m“%96C6 :D 6G:56?46 E92E D@>6 H:E?6DD6D C67FD65 E@ AC@G:56 E6DE:>@?J @C 277:52G:ED F?E:= 46CE2:? A2J>6?ED H6C6 C646:G65[” &]$] s:DEC:4E yF586 #] s2G:5 !C@4E6C HC@E6 :?k^DA2?m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]7@C36D]4@>^D:E6D^52?:6=7:D96C^a_`d^`a^`d^=23@C\C:89ED\=2HJ6C\A2:5\H:E?6DD6D\2?5\=:65\23@FE\:E\;F586\D2JD^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmkDA2?m2 a_`d @C56Ck^DA2?mk^2mkDA2?m] “%96C6 :D 6G:56?46 E92E r@==:?8DH@CE9 E9C62E6?65 E@ 4FE @77 A2J>6?ED @C 36?67:ED F?=6DD 96 H2D D2E:D7:65 H:E9 E96 6G:56?46 E96 H:E?6DD6D AC@5F465]”k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mr@==:?8DH@CE9 2?5 r@?C25 U2>Aj $496C6C 7@F89E sCF>>@?5’D 5:D4@G6CJ C6BF6DED 7@C J62CD[ 4:E:?8 2EE@C?6J\4=:6?E AC:G:=686[ 2?5 E96 42D6 H6?E E@ E96 ``E9 r:C4F:E r@FCE @7 pAA62=D EH:46] qFE :? s646>36C[ yF586 !C@4E6C @C56C65 E96 DE2CE @7 EC:2= 2?5 @? y2?] `d E96 ;FCJ 92?565 5@H? 2 G6C5:4Ei Sda >:==:@? 7@C 5672>2E:@? 2?5 Seg >:==:@? 7@C C24<6E66C:?8[ H9:49 :D EC:A=65 F?56C 7656C2= =2H]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mr@==:?8DH@CE9 2?5 9:D =2HJ6CD 5:5?’E :>>65:2E6=J C6DA@?5 E@ C6BF6DED 7@C 4@>>6?E] pE EC:2=[ sCF>>@?5 AC6D6?E65 6G:56?46 r@==:?8DH@CE9 2?5 r@?C25 U2>Aj $496C6C <?6H E96J H6C6 >2<:?8 A2J>6?ED E@ H:E?6DD6D[ FDF2==J 5:D8F:D65 2D 7@C “D64FC:EJ]” r@==:?8DH@CE9[ :? 2 a_`` 6>2:=[ D2:5 :E H2D ~z E@ A2J H:E?6DD6D[ 2D E96 “BF6DE:@? :D 5@:?8 D@ :? 2 H2J E@ >:?:>:K6 :>A24E @? 4C65:3:=:EJ]”k^DA2?mk^Am
More from this section
kAmkDA2?m$@>6 @7 E96 >@?6J 7=@H65 E@ t= %:8C6[ 2 7@C>6C >:=:E:2 =6256C H9@ 492?865 9:D E6DE:>@?J E@ :>A=:42E6 sCF>>@?5 27E6C C646:G:?8 :E[ sCF>>@?5 D2:5]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?m~E96C 6>2:=D D9@H r@==:?8DH@CE9 7C6EE:?8 @G6C 86EE:?8 2 Se_[___ A2J>6?E E@ 2 H:E?6DD H9@ H2D E9C62E6?:?8 E@ DE@A 4@@A6C2E:?8] x? 2==[ sCF>>@?5 D2:5 :E 7@F?5 6G:56?46 @7 S`b_[___ :? A2J>6?ED E@ @?6 <6J H:E?6DD[ 2 D>2== 7@CEF?6 :? r@=@>3:2] p?@E96C E6IE >6DD286 E@ r@==:?8DH@CE9 D2JD “:E’D F?56CDE@@5 ?@ >@?6J H:== 36 A2DD65 F?E:= 564=D 2C6 C646:G65[” >62?:?8 564=2C2E:@?D] sCF>>@?5 D2:5 E9@D6 56A@D:E:@?D H6C6 4C:E:42= E@ 7@==@H\@? =2HDF:ED r@==:?8DH@CE9 7:=65 282:?DE E96 >:?:?8 4@>A2?J :? a__h 27E6C E96 7:CDE H2D 5:D>:DD65]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mxE :D F?4=62C H96E96C sCF>>@?5 42? 4@==64E >F49 7C@> r@==:?8DH@CE9[ H9@D6 @C82?:K2E:@? :? (2D9:?8E@? 92D C6A@CE65 =6DD E92? Sd_[___ :? C6G6?F6 :? C646?E J62CD] w6 5@6D C6AC6D6?E 9F?5C65D @7 r@=@>3:2? A=2:?E:77D :? >F=E:5:DEC:4E =:E:82E:@? 282:?DE r9:BF:E2 E92E >:89E 92G6 2 36EE6C @FE4@>6]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mr9:BF:E2 A=65 8F:=EJ 2?5 A2:5 2 Sad >:==:@? 7:?6 :? a__f E@ D6EE=6 7656C2= 4C:>:?2= 492C86D :E 7F?565 2 E6CC@C:DE @C82?:K2E:@? 2?5 =@DE 2 Sbg >:==:@? G6C5:4E :? E96 7:CDE @7 D6G6C2= 6IA64E65 EC:2=D[ @A6?:?8 E96 A@DD:3:=:EJ @7 2 3:==:@?\5@==2C D6EE=6>6?E]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mr@==:?8DH@CE9 H2D =6DD DF446DD7F= DF:?8 }6DE=6 @G6C 2==6865 D=2G6CJ :? p7C:42] p 7656C2= ;F586 5:D>:DD65 E96 42D6[ E96 }:?E9 r:C4F:E C6G:G65 :E 2?5 E96 &]$] $FAC6>6 r@FCE C6G6CD65 :? 2 a_a` 564:D:@? =:>:E:?8 6IEC2E6CC:E@C:2= 2AA=:42E:@? @7 E96 p=:6? %@CE $E2EFE6[ 2 @?46\A@AF=2C E@@= 7@C DF:?8 4@>A2?:6D @? 3692=7 @7 7@C6:8? A=2:?E:77D]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mx? 2 AC6EC:2= 7:=:?8[ sCF>>@?5 D2:5 :E 925 DA6?E S`` >:==:@? @? =682= 766D 2?5 4=2:>65 S`d]d >:==:@? :? =@DE AC@7:ED 2?5 S`ec[___ 7=J:?8 E@ tFC@A6 E@ A=625 :ED 42D6 H:E9 }v~D 2?5 8@G6C?>6?E @77:4:2=D :? C6DA@?D6 E@ r@==:?8DH@CE9’D “6IEC2;F5:4:2= D>62C 42>A2:8?]”k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?m“%96 4@>A2?J 92D 6?5FC65 >2=:4:@FD 244FD2E:@?D 2?5 ?2CC2E:G6D 7@C 564256D[ H9:49 2 ;FCJ 92D ?@H F?2?:>@FD=J 56E6C>:?65 H6C6 42E68@C:42==J 72=D6[Q D2:5 %C6J (6==D @7 $E2C?6D s2G:D u=@C:6[ H9@ C6AC6D6?E65 sCF>>@?5]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2?mx? 2 >6>@[ r@==:?8DH@CE9 D2:5 9:D DEC2E68J H2D E@ “D6CG6 ?@E:46 @? sCF>>@?5’D 5@>6DE:4 2?5 H@C=5H:56 4FDE@>6C 32D6 E92E H96? E96J 5@ 3FD:?6DD H:E9 sCF>>@?5 E96J’C6 @?=J A6CA6EF2E:?8 56A=@C23=6 2?5 F?6E9:42= 4@CA@C2E6 >:D4@?5F4E 2?5 4C:>:?2=:EJ]” w:D E:>6D966E 7C@> a_`_ D9@HD C6A62E65 >66E:?8D H:E9 E96 9625 @7 2 {=2?@D ~:=[ 2 sFE49 7:C> E92E =@DE 2? @:= 4@?46DD:@? E@ sCF>>@?5[ 2D E96J EC:65 E@ 4@?G:?46 sFE49 @77:4:2=D E@ DE@A sCF>>@?5 7C@> 6IA@CE:?8 4@2= E@ E96 }6E96C=2?5D]k^DA2?mk^Am