Behind ideological attacks on higher ed, surprising bipartisan reforms are happening

kAmxE’D C2C6 :? 2? 6C2 @7 A2CE:D2? 5:G:D:@? E@ 962C 2 G6E6C2? @7 E96 r=:?E@? 2?5 ~32>2 AC6D:56?4:6D 28C66:?8 H:E9 2 C:89E\=62?:?8 64@?@>:DE H9@ H@C<65 7@C v6@C86 (] qFD9]k^Am

kAm*6E E96D6 AC@>:?6?E G@:46D 7C@> @AA@D:E6 6?5D @7 E96 A@=:E:42= DA64ECF> E62>65 FA E@ >@DE=J AC2:D6 2 =2H A2DD65 3J E96 #6AF3=:42? r@?8C6DD 2?5 D:8?65 3J !C6D:56?E s@?2=5 %CF>A]k^Am

kAm%96 AFCA@D6 @7 E96 =2Hi E@ AC@E64E 4@==686 DEF56?ED 7C@> 3@CC@H:?8 7656C2= >@?6J E@ 6?C@== :? AC@8C2>D E92E 8:G6 E96> =:EE=6 @C ?@ 7:?2?4:2= A2J@77 H96? E96J 8C25F2E6]k^Am

kAm%9:D ?6H CF=6 :D “E96 8C62E6DE DE6A 7@CH2C5 :? :?4C62D65 244@F?E23:=:EJ” 7@C 4@==686D D:?46 E96 4C62E:@? >@C6 E92? 2 564256 28@ @7 E96 7656C2= k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^4@==686D4@C642C5]65]8@G^Qmr@==686 $4@C642C5 H63D:E6k^2m[ H9:49 5:D4=@D6D 8C25F2E6D’ 62C?:?8D 3J :?DE:EFE:@?] %92E H2D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]C62=4=62C65F42E:@?]4@>^2CE:4=6D^a_ad^`a^_f^203:A2CE:D2?0DE6A0E@H2C50D>2CE6C04@==6860244@F?E23:=:EJ0``d`g`a]9E>=QmE96 4@?4=FD:@?k^2m @7 q@3 $9:C6>2?[ 2 D6?:@C 76==@H 2E E96 AC@8C6DD:G6 r6?EFCJ u@F?52E:@?[ 2?5 q6E9 p<6CD[ H9@ 9@=5D E96 D2>6 E:E=6 2E E96 4@?D6CG2E:G6 p>6C:42? t?E6CAC:D6 x?DE:EFE6[ @C ptx]k^Am

kAm%96 ?6H 244@F?E23:=:EJ CF=6 :D 2>@?8 2 D6C:6D @7 >62DFC6D E92E E96 =67E\=62?:?8 25G@424J 8C@FA t5%CFDE 42==D E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^65ECFDE]@C8^CE:^>2<:?8\E96\?6H\9:896C\65F42E:@?\244@F?E23:=:EJ\7C2>6H@C<\A2J\@77^n6>4:la36426b2\362b\7_``\g6e`\e_cd3565g32cU2>Aj6>5:l`a`53a5`\cg2c\7_``\g6e`\e_cd3565g32cU2>Aj46:5lb_d_`eQm>@DE 5C2>2E:4 492?86Dk^2m E@ 9:896C 65F42E:@? A@=:4J :? ?62C=J EH@ 564256D] |2?J H6C6 A2CE @7 E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4@?8C6DD]8@G^3:==^``hE9\4@?8C6DD^9@FD6\3:==^`^E6IE^69Qm~?6 q:8 q62FE:7F= q:== p4Ek^2m[ @C ~qqqp[ 2?5 H:== 364@>6 67764E:G6 E9:D J62C] p?5 D6G6C2= 4@F=5 :>AC@G6 AC@E64E:@?D 2?5 =@H6C 4@DED 7@C 72>:=:6D 2?5 DEF56?ED]k^Am

kAmxE >2J D66> 2 DFCAC:D6 E@ 962C 3:A2CE:D2? 244=2:> 7@C =2HD 27764E:?8 9:896C 65F42E:@? A2DD65 3J E9:D (9:E6 w@FD6 2?5 :ED 4@?8C6DD:@?2= 2==:6D] p7E6C 2==[ DF49 C67@C>D 4@>6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^9@H\65F42E:@?\492?865\:?\@?6\J62C\F?56C\ECF>A^Qm282:?DE E96 324<5C@Ak^2m @7 32?D @? 5:G6CD:EJ A@=:4:6D[ C6DEC:4E:@?D @? :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED[ 4FED E@ C6D62C49 7F?5:?8[ 9F86 7:?6D @? 6=:E6 F?:G6CD:E:6D[ 2?5 %CF>A’D C6=6?E=6DD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^I]4@>^6=@?>FD<^DE2EFD^`gde``cf`dehccccgdenC670DC4lEHDC4TdtE7HTfrEH42>ATdtEH66E6>365TfrEHE6C>Tdt`gde``cf`dehccccgdeTfrEH8CTdt7eccbff4e5de4d4253f3hca57fg`c5hd7eb7agb6TfrEH4@?TdtD`0U2>AjC670FC=l9EEADi^^HHH]?5EG]4@>^H@C=5\?6HD^E:>6\E@\C64=2:>\4@==686D\7C@>\C25:42=\=67E\5@?2=5\ECF>A\@?\65F42E:@?2=\@G6C92F=\ehhh`b`QmC96E@C:42= 2EE24<Dk^2m @? “C25:42=[” “H@<6” 42>AFD6D]k^Am

kAmqFE “E96C6 2C6 567:?:E6=J D@>6 A@D:E:G6 DE6AD E92E 92G6 366? E2<6?[” E@@[ D2:5 r2E96C:?6 qC@H?[ D6?:@C 5:C64E@C 7@C A@=:4J 2?5 25G@424J 2E E96 }2E:@?2= r@==686 pEE2:?>6?E }6EH@C<[ @C }rp}[ H9@ A2CE:4F=2C=J =:<6D 2? “62C?:?8D :?5:42E@C” 25565 E@ E96 upu$p[ @C uC66 pAA=:42E:@? 7@C u656C2= $EF56?E p:5] %92E E@@= k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7D2A2CE?6CD]65]8@G^<?@H=6586\46?E6C^=:3C2CJ^6=64EC@?:4\2??@F?46>6?ED^a_ad\`a\_b^?6H\=@H6C\62C?:?8D\:?5:42E@C\727D2C\7@C>QmH2C?D 4@==686 2AA=:42?EDk^2m E92E 8C25F2E6D 7C@> 2 A2CE:4F=2C D49@@= H:E9 E96 >2;@CD E96J’C6 4@?D:56C:?8 92G6 9:DE@C:42==J 62C?65 ?@ >@C6 E92? E9@D6 H:E9 @?=J 2 9:89 D49@@= 5:A=@>2]k^Am

kAm“p =@E @7 E:>6D E96 3:8 9625=:?6D — =:<6[ ‘(6 H2?E E@ 4FE 7F?5:?8 7@C 9:896C 65F42E:@?’ — 4C62E6 2 4F=EFC6 H96C6 :E’D ?@E 62DJ E@ D66 :>AC@G6>6?ED E92E 2C6 36:?8 >256[” qC@H? D2:5]k^Am

kAm~E96C 492?86D :?4=F56 E96 @G6C92F= @7 2? 244C65:E2E:@? DJDE6> E92E 92D =@?8 72:=65 E@ :>AC@G6 A@@C 8C25F2E:@? C2E6D 2E >2?J 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6Dj =:>:ED @? 3@CC@H:?8 7@C 8C25F2E6 D49@@=[ H9:49 6IA6CED D2J 4@F=5 96=A 5C:G6 5@H? E96 AC:46j 2?5 E96 6IA2?D:@? @7 7656C2= !6== vC2?E 6=:8:3:=:EJ — AC6G:@FD=J 2G2:=23=6 @?=J E@ 568C66\D66<:?8 4@==686 DEF56?ED — E@ D9@CE6C\E6C> ;@3 EC2:?:?8[ :?4=F5:?8 :? E96 EC256D]k^Am

kAm|2?J @7 E96 D2>6 DE6AD H6C6 AC@A@D65 3J 62C=:6C AC6D:56?ED 2?5 =2H>2<6CD 7C@> 3@E9 A2CE:6D[ 3FE =2C86=J C6D:DE65 3J F?:G6CD:E:6D 2?5 4@==686D E96>D6=G6D]k^Am

kAm“!@=:4J>2<6CD 7C@> 3@E9 D:56D @7 E96 2:D=6 2?5 @7 2== A@=:E:42= DEC:A6D 92G6 H2?E65 D@>6 @7 E96D6 E9:?8D 7@C 2 =@?8 E:>6 ?@H[” D2:5 t5 '6?:E[ >2?28:?8 5:C64E@C 2E E96 9:896C 65F42E:@? 4@?DF=E:?8 7:C> tpq]k^Am

kAmtG6? D@>6 @7 E96 >@C6 4@?EC@G6CD:2= >@G6D 92G6 E96 A@E6?E:2= 7@C A@D:E:G6 492?86[ D@>6 2?2=JDED 2?5 25G@42E6D 2C8F6] (9:=6 E2I:?8 4@==686 2?5 F?:G6CD:EJ 6?5@H>6?ED :D 4@?E6?E:@FD[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ E96J D2J :E 4@F=5 5C:G6 E@A :?DE:EFE:@?D E@ 6IE6?5 E96 36?67:ED E96J @776C E@ >@C6 DEF56?ED]k^Am

kAm%@ 36 DFC6[ E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 2AA62CD E@ 92G6 DFAA@CE65 D@>6 @7 E96D6 C67@C>D 7@C :56@=@8:42= 2?5 6G6? AF?:E:G6 AFCA@D6D[ C2E96C E92? E96 C62D@?D 62C=:6C 25>:?:DEC2E:@?D EC:65 E@ 86E E96> A2DD65]k^Am

kAm%2I:?8 6?5@H>6?ED[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ >@DE=J 9FCED E96 H62=E9J[ D6=64E:G6 F?:G6CD:E:6D 2?5 4@==686D E92E E96 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 92D E2C86E65 7@C 92G:?8 5:G6CD:EJ A@=:4:6D] p?5 EC2?D7@C>:?8 244C65:E2E:@? — E96 56 724E@ BF2=:EJ\4@?EC@= DJDE6> E92E 8@G6C?D H96E96C 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6D 42? 36 A2:5 H:E9 7656C2= 8C2?ED 2?5 =@2?D — 2=D@ 2AA62CD 56D:8?65 E@ AF?:D9 244C65:E@CD E92E AFD9 5:G6CD:EJ 2?5 D2?4E:@? E96 E6249:?8 @7 DF3;64ED 4@?D6CG2E:G6D @AA@D6[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 AC6D:56?E 9:>D6=7]k^Am

kAmp44C65:E2E:@? :D “@FC D64C6E H62A@?[” %CF>A k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^I]4@>^6=@?>FD<^DE2EFD^`gde``cf`dehccccgdenC670DC4lEHDC4TdtE7HTfrEH42>ATdtEH66E6>365TfrEHE6C>Tdt`gde``cf`dehccccgdeTfrEH8CTdt7eccbff4e5de4d4253f3hca57fg`c5hd7eb7agb6TfrEH4@?TdtD`0U2>AjC670FC=l9EEADi^^HHH]?5EG]4@>^H@C=5\?6HD^E:>6\E@\C64=2:>\4@==686D\7C@>\C25:42=\=67E\5@?2=5\ECF>A\@?\65F42E:@?2=\@G6C92F=\ehhh`b`Qm92D D2:5k^2m[ E@ 86E C:5 @7 H92E 96 42==65 “|2CI:DE >2?:24D 2?5 =F?2E:4D” 2E p>6C:42? F?:G6CD:E:6D] w:D 25>:?:DEC2E:@? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]65]8@G^23@FE^?6HD^AC6DD\C6=62D6^FD\56A2CE>6?E\@7\65F42E:@?\2??@F?46D\?68@E:2E65\CF=6>2<:?8\C67@C>\2?5\DEC6?8E96?\2>6C:42D\9:896C\65F42E:@?\244C65:E2E:@?\DJDE6>Qm92D 72DE\EC24<65k^2m E96 AC@46DD @7 255:?8 ?6H 244C65:E@CD E92E 96 D2:5 H:== AC@>@E6 “E96 p>6C:42? EC25:E:@? 2?5 H6DE6C? 4:G:=:K2E:@?]”k^Am

kAm%92E H@CC:6D 24256>:4D 2?5 @E96CD 4@?46C?65 H:E9 ?6H 2?5 AC@DA64E:G6 C6DEC:4E:@?D @? 4=2DDC@@> 2?5 42>AFD DA6649]k^Am

kAmqFE :E :D 2=D@ ECF6 E92E 6I:DE:?8 244C65:E2E:@? 286?4:6D 92G6 4@?E:?F65 E@ 244C65:E 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7:=6D]6C:4]65]8@G^7F==E6IE^tse`bfgb]A57QmE92E H6C6 567C2F5:?8 DEF56?EDk^2m @C 92G6 23JD>2= 8C25F2E:@? C2E6D] }62C=J c :? `_ 244C65:E65 :?DE:EFE:@?D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E9:C5H2J]@C8^3=@8^H96?\H:==\E96\H2E495@8D\3:E6Qm8C25F2E6 76H6C E92? 92=7 @7 E96:C DEF56?EDk^2m H9:=6 36:?8 2==@H65 E@ 4@==64E 3:==:@?D @7 5@==2CD :? 7656C2= E2IA2J6C >@?6J[ C6D62C49 D9@HD]k^Am

kAm“%96D6 2C6 DFAA@D65 E@ 36 E96 H2E495@8D @7 9:896C 65F42E:@?[ 2?5 D@>6 @7 E96> 92G6 ?@E 366? 5@:?8 2 G6CJ 8@@5 ;@3[” D2:5 !C6DE@? r@@A6C[ 2 D6?:@C 76==@H 2E ptx]k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]9:896C655:G6]4@>^?6HD^@32>2\25>:?:DEC2E:@?\:>A@D6D\?6H\C6BF:C6>6?ED\@?\244C65:E@CD^c_ggcc^Qms6>@4C2E:4k^2m 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]8@GEC24<]FD^4@?8C6DD^3:==D^`_a^D``d_^DF>>2CJQm#6AF3=:42?k^2m 25>:?:DEC2E:@?D 92G6 EC:65 7@C 564256D E@ >2<6 E96 244C65:E2E:@? DJDE6> >@C6 244@F?E23=6 7@C A@@C @FE4@>6D]k^Am

kAmtG6? 25G@42E6D H9@ =:<6 D@>6 @7 E96 72DE\>@G:?8 492?86D F?56CH2J 2C6 C2:D:?8 4@?46C?D 23@FE E96 7:?6 AC:?E]k^Am

kAm(9:=6 $9:C6>2? 2?5 p<6CD 86?6C2==J H6=4@>65 E92E ?6H CF=6 3=@4<:?8 7656C2= DEF56?E =@2?D 7C@> 36:?8 FD65 7@C >2;@CD 2?5 AC@8C2>D H:E9 =@H 7:?2?4:2= C6EFC?D[ 7@C :?DE2?46[ :E’D 42==65 pwtps[ 7@C p44@F?E23:=:EJ :? w:896C t5F42E:@? 2?5 p446DD %9C@F89 s6>2?5\5C:G6? (@C<7@C46 !6== — E96J ?@E65 E92E E96 42=4F=2E:@? H:== 36 32D65 @? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]65]8@G^23@FE^?6HD^AC6DD\C6=62D6^FD\56A2CE>6?E\@7\65F42E:@?\C62496D\4@?D6?DFD\9:DE@C:4\?6H\244@F?E23:=:EJ\7C2>6H@C<\2?5\4@?4=F56D\9:896C\65F42E:@?\C67@C>\CF=6>2<:?8\D6DD:@?DQm9@H >F49 8C25F2E6D 7C@> E96D6 AC@8C2>D 62C?k^2m 2?5 ?@E 9@H >F49 E96J A2:5 7@C E96:C 568C66D] %92E >62?D DEF56?ED H:== DE:== 92G6 2446DD E@ =@2?D E@ A2J 7@C >2;@CD H9@D6 8C25F2E6D >2<6 H92E =@@< =:<6 8@@5 H286D[ 3FE ?@E 6?@F89 E@ 4@G6C H92E E96J 3@CC@H65]k^Am

kAm$E:==[ :E’D 2 DE6A E@H2C5 244@F?E23:=:EJ E92E A@=:4J>2<6CD 92G6 366? D66<:?8 D:?46 E96 ~32>2 25>:?:DEC2E:@?[ H9:49 EC:65 E@ 6?5 6=:8:3:=:EJ 7@C 7656C2= 7:?2?4:2= 2:5 7@C F?:G6CD:EJ 2?5 4@==686 AC@8C2>D H9@D6 8C25F2E6D’ DEF56?E =@2? 563E 6I466565 2 8:G6? A6C46?E286 @7 E96:C 62C?:?8D — E96 D@\42==65 82:?7F= 6>A=@J>6?E CF=6]k^Am

kAm“~?6 @7 E96 E9:?8D 6G6CJ3@5J 28C66D @? :D H6 D9@F=5 C2:D6 :?5:G:5F2= 64@?@>:4 >@3:=:EJ 7@C DEF56?ED[” tpq’D '6?:E D2:5] “%96J D9@F=5 4@>6 @FE 36EE6C E92? E96J H6?E :?[ 2?5 46CE2:?=J ?@ H@CD6] %9:D :D D@>6E9:?8 6G6CJ3@5J H2?ED]”k^Am

kAmpwtps[ H9:49 :D D4965F=65 E@ E2<6 67764E :? yF=J[ H:== 27764E AC@8C2>D 6?C@==:?8 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]65]8@G^23@FE^?6HD^AC6DD\C6=62D6^FD\56A2CE>6?E\@7\65F42E:@?\=2F?496D\?6H\62C?:?8D\:?5:42E@C\DFAA@CE\DEF56?ED\2?5\72>:=:6D\>2<:?8\:?7@C>65\4@==686\564:D:@?DQm>@C6 E92? aT @7 DEF56?EDk^2m[ E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 t5F42E:@? 6DE:>2E6D[ >@DE @7 E96> 2E 7@C\AC@7:E 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6D] %92E’D 23@FE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E9:C5H2J]@C8^3=@8^H92E\H:==\92AA6?\:7\H6\C6:?DE2E6\E96\82:?7F=\6>A=@J>6?E\CF=6Qm2 E9:C5 @7 E96 AC@A@CE:@?k^2m E92E H@F=5 92G6 72:=65 E96 >@DE C646?E 82:?7F= 6>A=@J>6?E C68F=2E:@? AFD965 3J E96 q:56? 25>:?:DEC2E:@?[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 2? 2?2=JD:D 3J E96 46?E6C\=67E 25G@424J @C82?:K2E:@? %9:C5 (2J]k^Am

kAm“|2J36 ?6:E96C D:56 86ED 6G6CJE9:?8 E96J H2?E] qFE H6’G6 =2?565 @? D@>6E9:?8 E92E 42? >2<6 E96 244@F?E23:=:EJ 25G@42E6D @? 3@E9 D:56D 4@?E6?E[” D2:5 r@@A6C[ H9@ D6CG65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]65]8@G^>65:2^5@4F>6?E^a_ad\29625\4@>>:EE:6\=:DE\``adbc]A57Qm@? E96 4@>>:EE66k^2m E92E 7:?2=:K65 E96 CF=6]k^Am

kAmp>6C:42?D 7C@> 3@E9 A2CE:6D[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?6H2>6C:42]@C8^65F42E:@?\A@=:4J^6546?EC2=^2>6C:42?D\2C6\F?:E65\@?\244@F?E23:=:EJ^Qm3J H:56 >2C8:?Dk^2m[ DFAA@CE 4FEE:?8 @77 E2I 5@==2CD E@ AC@8C2>D H:E9 A@@C 7:?2?4:2= A2J@77D[ 2 DFCG6J 3J E96 =67E\=62?:?8 }6H p>6C:42 u@F?52E:@? 7@F?5]k^Am

kAm%H@\E9:C5D[ :? 2 D6A2C2E6 DFCG6J 3J E96 DEF56?E =@2? AC@G:56C $2==:6 |26[ D2:5 E96J H6C6 2=D@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D2==:6>26]4@>^23@FE^=625:?8\C6D62C49^9@H\2>6C:42\A2JD\7@C\4@==686^Qm:? 72G@Ck^2m @7 =:>:ED @? DEF56?E 3@CC@H:?8]k^Am

kAm&?56C8C25F2E6 DEF56?E =@2?D 2C6 2=C625J 42AA65] qFE =:>:ED H6C6 C6>@G65 7@C 8C25F2E6 DEF56?ED 3J 2? 62C=:6C #6AF3=:42?\4@?EC@==65 r@?8C6DD :? a__e] vC25F2E6 D49@@=D E@@< 25G2?E286 @7 E9:D =2C86C A@@= @7 >@?6J 3J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=6D=6J;EFC?6C]4@>^q=24<%FC?6Cs6??:?80vC25!{&$]A57QmC2:D:?8 E96:C =:DE65 AC:46Dk^2m 3J S` 7@C 6G6CJ 5@==2C DEF56?ED 3@CC@H65[ 244@C5:?8 E@ C6D62C496CD 2E E96 F?:G6CD:E:6D @7 %6I2D 2?5 r9:428@] vC25F2E6 DEF56?E 563E 6IA=@565]k^Am

kAmp5G@42E6D @? 3@E9 E96 =67E 2?5 C:89E 92G6 42==65 D:?46 2E =62DE a_ab 7@C 42AD @? 8C25F2E6 3@CC@H:?8 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]26:]@C8^C6D62C49\AC@5F4ED^C6A@CE^2\7C2>6H@C<\7@C\C67@C>:?8\7656C2=\8C25F2E6\DEF56?E\2:5\A@=:4J^QmE@ 36 C6DE@C65k^2m[ H9:49 E96 4FCC6?E r@?8C6DD 92D ?@H @C56C65] q68:??:?8 :? yF=J[ >@DE 8C25F2E6 DEF56?ED k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]65]8@G^23@FE^?6HD^AC6DD\C6=62D6^FD\56A2CE>6?E\@7\65F42E:@?\:DDF6D\AC@A@D65\CF=6\>2<6\9:896C\65F42E:@?\>@C6\277@C523=6\2?5\D:>A=:7J\DEF56?E\=@2?\C6A2J>6?EQmH:== 36 =:>:E65k^2m E@ 2 >2I:>F> @7 Sa_[d__ 2 J62C :? 7656C2= =@2?D[ 7@C 2 E@E2= @7 S`__[___j E96 E@A 2>@F?E 7@C AC@76DD:@?2= AC@8C2>D DF49 2D >65:4:?6 2?5 =2H H:== 36 Sd_[___[ @C 2 E@E2= @7 Sa__[___]k^Am

kAm%96 492?86 H:== 27764E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A9:=256=A9:2765]@C8^\^>65:2^u#q!^pDD6ED^r@?DF>6C\u:?2?46^#6A@CED^DEF56?E\=@2?D\7@C\8C25F2E6\D49@@=]A57nFE>0D@FC46lxE6C23=6U2>AjFE>0>65:F>l6>2:=U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?l42>A2:8?0`e`d`acg0?=0s2:=J\qC:67:?8052E60a_ad`a`gQm23@FE 2 E9:C5k^2m @7 8C25F2E6 DEF56?ED 2?5 92=7 @7 DEF56?ED :? AC@76DD:@?2= D49@@=D H9@ 4FCC6?E=J 3@CC@H >@C6 E92? E92E[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 u656C2= #6D6CG6 q2?< @7 !9:=256=A9:2[ H9:49 AC65:4ED E92E >2?J H:== 36 7@C465 E@ EFC? E@ AC:G2E6 =6?56CD E@ >2<6 FA E96 5:776C6?46] %9:D D6E @77 2 ?2E:@?2= 7:C6DE@C> 2D ?FCD:?8 2?5 @E96C AC@76DD:@?D H6C6 56?:65 AC@76DD:@?2= DE2EFD]k^Am

kAmqFE E96C6 2C6 :?5:42E:@?D E92E E96 42AD >2J 7@C46 8C25F2E6 AC@8C2>D E@ D=@H EF:E:@? :?4C62D6D 2?5 D9FE 5@H? 9:89\AC:465 AC@8C2>D] %96 $2?E2 r=2C2 &?:G6CD:EJ $49@@= @7 {2H :? r2=:7@C?:2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=2H]D4F]65F^?6HD\6G6?ED^?6HD^a_ad^D2?E2\4=2C2\=2H\=2F?496D\8C@F?53C62<:?8\A=6586\D49@=2CD9:A\7@C\72==\a_ae\:?4@>:?8\DEF56?ED]9E>=Qm92D 2=C625J AC@>:D65k^2m S`e[___ D49@=2CD9:AD E@ 6?E6C:?8 DEF56?ED E@ “@77D6E E96 :>A24E” @7 E96D6 ?6H =@2? =:>:ED 2?5 3C:?8 :ED Seb[ag_ 2??F2= EF:E:@? :?E@ =:?6 H:E9 E96>]k^Am

kAm“%9:D 92D 366? E96 >@DE 4@?EC@G6CD:2= A=2?< @7 E96 C67@C>D[ 3FE :E’D 2 >2;@C DE6A 7@CH2C5 E@ 4@DE 4@?EC@= 2?5 EC:>>:?8 8@G6C?>6?E DF3D:5:6D E@ AC@8C2>D E92E 4@DE E@@ >F49 2?5 >2J ?@E 36 56=:G6C:?8 G2=F6[” r@@A6C D2:5]k^Am

kAm%96C6’D 2=D@ 366? 3:A2CE:D2? DFAA@CE 7@C AFD9:?8 D6=64E:G6 :?DE:EFE:@?D E@ 2446AE >@C6 DEF56?ED 2?5 DA6?5 >@C6 @7 E96:C H62=E9 @? 7:?2?4:2= 2:5] %2I:?8 6?5@H>6?ED 2E E96 H62=E9:6DE D49@@=D 4@F=5 5C:G6 E96> E@ 6IA2?5[ D@>6 2?2=JDED 92G6 2C8F65]k^Am

kAmq642FD6 E96 E2I :D 32D65 @? 6?C@==>6?E — 27764E:?8 @?=J F?:G6CD:E:6D E92E 92G6 E96 6BF:G2=6?E @7 Sd__[___ :? 9@=5:?8D A6C DEF56?E — D@>6 4@F=5 2G@:5 :E 3J =6EE:?8 :? >@C6 2AA=:42?ED[ r@@A6C 2?5 @E96CD D2J]k^Am

kAm“u@C :?DE:EFE:@?D E92E 2C6 G6CJ 4=@D6 E@ E96 42A[ :?4C62D:?8 J@FC 6?C@==>6?ED >:89E ?@E 36 2 325 :562[” 96 D2:5] “p =@E @7 6=:E6 F?:G6CD:E:6D 2C6 C6=J:?8 @? 6I4=FD:G:EJ E@ ECJ 2?5 D9@H G2=F6[ 2?5 3J 6IA2?5:?8 E96:C 6?C@==>6?E 2 3:E[ E92E >:89E 8:G6 >@C6 DEF56?ED 2446DD E@ H92E6G6C E96 36?67:ED 2C6 @7 8@:?8 E@ E9@D6 D49@@=D]”k^Am

kAmqC@H? &?:G6CD:EJ[ 7@C :?DE2?46[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]26:]@C8^65F42E:@?^4@F=5\2\9:896C\6?5@H>6?E\E2I\AC6DDFC6\6=:E6\D49@@=D\E@\6IA2?5^Qm4@F=5 2G@:5 E96 E2Ik^2m 3J E2<:?8 23@FE ad_ >@C6 DEF56?ED A6C 4=2DD[ 2 `_T :?4C62D6[ 2? 2?2=JD:D 3J r@@A6C 7@F?5]k^Am

kAm}@E 2== @7 E96 492?86D AC@A@D65 3J #6AF3=:42?D :? r@?8C6DD 92G6 A2DD65[ 2?5 4@FCED 92G6 96=5 FA @E96CD E92E H6C6 E96 DF3;64E @7 6I64FE:G6 @C56CD]k^Am

kAmp %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 2EE6>AE E@ =:>:E C6:>3FCD6>6?ED 7@C 6IA6?D6D C6=2E65 E@ E96 7656C2= C6D62C49 F?:G6CD:E:6D 4@?5F4E[ 7@C 6I2>A=6 — E96 4@DE @7 =23D[ FE:=:E:6D[ DFAA=:6D[ 2?5 >2?A@H6C — 92D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]42`]FD4@FCED]8@G^D:E6D^42`^7:=6D^@A?7:=6D^ad\`bcb!\_`p]A57Qm366? 3=@4<65k^2m 3J 2 7656C2= 2AA62=D 4@FCE[ H9:49 28C665 H:E9 2 =@H6C 4@FCE E92E :E H2D “2C3:EC2CJ 2?5 42AC:4:@FD” 2?5 :? G:@=2E:@? @7 E96 C6BF:C65 =682= AC@46DD]k^Am

kAm{2H>2<6CD @? E96 =67E 2?5 C:89E 92G6 42==65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4@?8C6DD]8@G^4CD06IE6C?2=0AC@5F4ED^#^!su^#cgdc_^#cgdc_]`]A57QmD:?46 E96 `hg_Dk^2m 7@C 4@?E2:?:?8 E96D6 4@DED] p7E6C D@>6 F?:G6CD:E:6D H6C6 5:D4@G6C65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^>:ED=@2?]>:E]65F^D92C65^@5D^5@4F>6?EDn!F3=:42E:@?s@4F>6?Exsl`_dgfQm>:DFD:?8 E96 >@?6Jk^2m — 2E $E2?7@C5 &?:G6CD:EJ[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ @? 2? 2?E:BF6 4@>>@56 2?5 56AC64:2E:@? @? 2 J249E — !C6D:56?E q:== r=:?E@? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4@?8C6DD]8@G^4CD\AC@5F4E^#cgdc_QmEC:65 E@ =:>:Ek^2m 7656C2= C6:>3FCD6>6?ED 2D 2 AC@A@CE:@? @7 E96 G2=F6 @7 C6D62C49 8C2?ED[ E9@F89 ?@E 2D D6G6C6 2D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^8C2?ED]?:9]8@G^8C2?ED^8F:56^?@E:46\7:=6D^}~%\~s\ad\_eg]9E>=QmE96 `dT >2I:>F>k^2m E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? :D 2EE6>AE:?8 E@ :>A@D6]k^Am

kAmp AC@A@D2= 5C@AA65 7C@> E96 ~qqqp H@F=5 92G6 >256 4@==686D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]26:]@C8^C6D62C49\AC@5F4ED^C6A@CE^C:D<\D92C:?8\E96\DEF56?E\=@2?\C67@C>\H9@D6\E:>6\92D\4@>6^QmC6:>3FCD6 E96 8@G6C?>6?Ek^2m H96? E96:C DEF56?ED 5672F=E @? 7656C2= =@2?D] p?@E96C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?2D722]@C8^?6HD\:E6>^be`hf^#64@?4:=:2E:@?0s66A0s:G60w@FD60r@>>:EE660!C@A@D6D0|2;@C0r92?86D0E@0!6==0vC2?E0r2>AFD\q2D650p:50}665\p?2=JD:D02?50$EF56?E0t=:8:3:=:EJQmE92E H2D 4FEk^2m H@F=5 92G6 EC:65 E@ :>AC@G6 4@>A=6E:@? C2E6D 3J C6BF:C:?8 DEF56?ED C646:G:?8 7656C2= !6== vC2?ED[ H9:49 96=A =@H6C\:?4@>6 72>:=:6D A2J 7@C 4@==686[ E@ 4@>A=6E6 2E =62DE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?2D722]@C8^?6HD\:E6>^be`hf^#64@?4:=:2E:@?0s66A0s:G60w@FD60r@>>:EE660!C@A@D6D0|2;@C0r92?86D0E@0!6==0vC2?E0r2>AFD\q2D650p:50}665\p?2=JD:D02?50$EF56?E0t=:8:3:=:EJQmb_ 4C65:ED 2 J62Ck^2m — E96 >:?:>F> EJA:42==J ?66565 E@ 8C25F2E6 @? E:>6 H:E9 2 568C66] %92E’D FA 7C@> E96 4FCC6?E ac 4C65:ED]k^Am

kAmv6EE:?8 7656C2= 7:?2?4:2= 2:5 :? E96 7:CDE A=246 H2D :ED6=7 DA65 FA 7@C >2?J DEF56?ED H96? E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? C@==65 @FE E96 7@C> C6BF:C65 E@ 5@ :E[ E96 upu$p[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]65]8@G^23@FE^?6HD^AC6DD\C6=62D6^FD\56A2CE>6?E\@7\65F42E:@?\C62496D\9:DE@C:4\>:=6DE@?6\727D2\4@>A=6E:@?DQm:? $6AE6>36C C2E96C E92? s646>36Ck^2m[ 2D :? A2DE J62CD] %96 ?F>36C @7 DF3>:DD:@?D :? E96 72== >@C6 E92? 5@F3=65 @G6C E96 AC6G:@FD 72==[ 96=A65 2=D@ 3J 62C=:6C H@C< 3J 3@E9 A2CE:6D E@ >2<6 E96 7@C> D:>A=6C]k^Am

kAm“%96J’C6 ?@E E96 D6I:6DE 492?86D[ 3FE D@>6 @7 E96 upu$p E649?:42= 492?86D 92G6 366? 9F86=J 4@?D6BF6?E:2=[” D2:5 qC@H?[ 2E }rp}] “$@>6 @7 E96D6 D>2== E9:?8D 42? >2<6 2 3:8 5:776C6?46 :? E6C>D @7 DEF56?ED F=E:>2E6=J 8@:?8 E@ 4@==686]”k^Am

kAm~E96C =@?8\D@F89E AC@A@D2=D 2C6 ?@H 82:?:?8 EC24E:@?[ :?4=F5:?8 @?6 E92E H@F=5 >2<6 :E 62D:6C 7@C DEF56?ED 2?5 72>:=:6D E@ F?56CDE2?5 H92E 4@==686 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4@?8C6DD]8@G^3:==^``hE9\4@?8C6DD^D6?2E6\3:==^ad``^E6IE^:DQmH:== 24EF2==J 4@DE E96>k^2m 2?5 4@>A2C6 AC:46D — D@>6E9:?8 :?DE:EFE:@?D ?@H >2<6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^765D\AC@G:56\:?7@\@?\4@==686D\E96J\D2J\H:==\96=A\4@?DF>6CD\2G@:5\325\24E@CD^Qm4@?7@F?5:?8=J 5:77:4F=Ek^2m E@ 5@] w2=7 @7 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6D E6== AC@DA64E:G6 DEF56?ED k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]82@]8@G^2DD6ED^82@\ab\`_cf_g]A57QmE96J’== A2J =6DD E92? E96J 24EF2==J H:==k^2m[ 2?5 >@C6 E92? c_T 5@?’E 5:D4=@D6 E96 4@DE 2E 2==[ 2 v@G6C?>6?E p44@F?E23:=:EJ ~77:46 DEF5J 7@F?5]k^Am

kAmq:==D E@ 492?86 E9:D 92G6 366? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4@?8C6DD]8@G^3:==^``dE9\4@?8C6DD^9@FD6\3:==^acbcnBlTfqTaaD62C49TaaiTaaTdrTaar@==686Z%C2?DA2C6?4JZp4ETdrTaaTaaTfsU2>AjDlfU2>AjClfQm:?EC@5F465 C6A62E65=J D:?46 a_`fk^2m[ H:E9 3C@25 3:A2CE:D2? DFAA@CE[ :?4=F5:?8 7C@> s6>@4C2E:4 $6?2E@C t=:K236E9 (2CC6? 2?5 #6AF3=:42? $6?2E@C q:== r2DD:5J[ H9@ 2C6 2>@?8 E96 ?6H 3:==’D DA@?D@CD]k^Am

kAm“u@C 2D >F49 2EE6?E:@? 2D E96C6 2=H2JD :D @? 9@H >F49 A2CE:D2?D9:A 6I:DED :? (2D9:?8E@? s]r][ :E’D @7E6? @G6C=@@<65 9@H >F49 3:A2CE:D2? 28C66>6?E E96C6 :D @? E9:?8D =:<6 AC:46 EC2?DA2C6?4J[” D2:5 yFDE:? sC2686C[ D6?:@C G:46 AC6D:56?E 7@C 277@C523:=:EJ 2E E96 $EC252 t5F42E:@? u@F?52E:@?] W$EC252 :D 2>@?8 E96 >2?J 7F?56CD @7 %96 w649:?86C #6A@CE[ H9:49 AC@5F465 E9:D DE@CJ]Xk^Am

kAm“pD E96 4@DE 3FC56? 92D D9:7E65 >@C6 E@ DEF56?ED 2?5 72>:=:6D[ E96J’C6 2D<:?8 BF6DE:@?D 23@FE H92E :D E96 A2J@77 8@:?8 E@ 36[” sC2686C D2:5] “p?5 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6D 92G6 E@ 36 23=6 E@ 2?DH6C E92E 7@C E96>]”k^Am

kAm%96 ?6H 2EE6>AE E@ AFD9 E9:D E9C@F89 :D A2CE @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]96=A]D6?2E6]8@G^:>@^>65:2^5@4^=@H6C:?8065F42E:@?04@DED02?50563E024E]A57Qm2 A24<286 @7 3:==Dk^2m ?@H F?56C 4@?D:56C2E:@?[ :?4=F5:?8 @?6 E92E H@F=5 C6BF:C6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]9FDE65]D6?2E6]8@G^HA\4@?E6?E^FA=@25D^a_ad^_h^strxst\p4E]A57QmC6A@CE:?8 E96 62C?:?8D 2?5 42C66C @FE4@>6Dk^2m @7 8C25F2E6D 7C@> G2C:@FD >2;@CD[ 2=@?8 H:E9 E96:C 2G6C286 =@2? 563E] !@DE8C25F2E6 A=246>6?E C2E6D 2?5 :?4@>6D AC@G:565 3J 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6D E@52J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^C2?<:?8D\6I@5FD\C2:D6D\E96\BF6DE:@?\9@H\D9@F=5\4@?DF>6CD\A:4<\2\4@==686^Qm2C6 @7E6? >:D=625:?8 2?5 :?244FC2E6k^2m]k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A6HC6D62C49]@C8^D@4:2=\EC6?5D^a_ac^_d^ab^AF3=:4\G:6HD\@?\E96\G2=F6\@7\2\4@==686\568C66^QmvC@H:?8 AF3=:4 D<6AE:4:D>k^2m 23@FE E96 G2=F6 @7 568C66D[ >@C6 E92? A@=:E:4D[ >2J[ :? E96 6?5[ 36 H92E’D 244@F?E:?8 7@C E9:D 7=FCCJ @7 ?6H CF=6D[ D2:5 r@@A6C[ @7 ptx]k^Am

kAm“%96 E9C625 CF??:?8 E9C@F89 2 =@E @7 E96D6 492?86D[” 96 D2:5[ “:D 2 =24< @7 ECFDE :? F?:G6CD:E:6D E@ 2=H2JD 5@ E96 C:89E E9:?8]”k^Am

kAmk6>m%9:D DE@CJ 2=D@ 2AA62C65 :?k^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^H2D9:?8E@?>@?E9=J]4@>^Qmk6>m(2D9:?8E@? |@?E9=Jk^6>mk^2m]k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^369:?5\:56@=@8:42=\2EE24<D\@?\9:896C\65\DFCAC:D:?8\3:A2CE:D2?\C67@C>D\2C6\92AA6?:?8^Qmk6>m%9:D DE@CJk^6>mk^2m k6>mH2D AC@5F465 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^Qmk6>m%96 w649:?86C #6A@CEk^6>mk^2mk6>m[ 2 ?@?AC@7:E[ :?56A6?56?E ?6HD @C82?:K2E:@? 7@4FD65 @? :?6BF2=:EJ 2?5 :??@G2E:@? :? 65F42E:@?[ 2?5 C6G:6H65 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F3D]=2^"_b<=8$#_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmk6>m$E24<6Ck^6>mk^2m]k^Am