Homes on the range: Is a federal affordable housing policy leading to a public lands selloff?

kAmu@C DE2776CD 2E 4@?D6CG2E:@? 8C@FAD =:<6 %96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ 2?5 s676?56CD @7 (:=5=:76[ E96 52:=J C@FE:?6 @7E6? :?G@=G6D EC24<:?8 4@?8C6DD:@?2= =68:D=2E:@? 2?5 6I64FE:G6 3C2?49 24E:@?D E92E[ :? D@>6 42D6D[ =@@< =:<6 EC@F3=6[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]C6AF3=:4]=2?5^Qm#ti!&q{xrk^2m C6A@CED] x? E96 62C=J >@?E9D @7 E96 D64@?5 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@?[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ C25:42= 492?86D DE2CE65 92AA6?:?8 72DE—2>@?8 E96>[ E96 s~vt\A@H6C65 '2=6?E:?6’D s2J DE277:?8 4FED 2E E96 }2E:@?2= !2C< $6CG:46 2?5 E96 &]$] u@C6DE $6CG:46]k^Am

kAmsFC:?8 E9:D A6C:@5[ 2 5:776C6?E AC@A@D2= 6>6C865 E92E 5:5?’E 86E ?62C=J 2D >F49 2EE6?E:@? 7C@> E96 >65:2 2?5 AF3=:4[ 3FE :E D@F?565 =:<6 2 42FD6 7@C 4@?46C?] xE 46?E6C65 @? 2 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? AFD9 E@ 255 2 ?6H 42E68@CJ @7 “>F=E:A=6 FD6” E@ E96 EC25:E:@?2= >6?F @7 >:?:?8[ 8C2K:?8[ 2?5 E:>36C 92CG6DE:?8i E96 4@?DECF4E:@? @7 277@C523=6 9@FD:?8]k^Am

kAm~? |2C49 `e[ a_ad[ E96 D64C6E2C:6D @7 E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 E96 x?E6C:@C 2?5 E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 w@FD:?8 2?5 &C32? s6G6=@A>6?E 2??@F?465 E96 4C62E:@? @7 2 “k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]5@:]8@G^AC6DDC6=62D6D^:4J>:\D64C6E2CJ\3FC8F>\9F5\D64C6E2CJ\EFC?6C\2??@F?46\;@:?E\E2D<\7@C46\C65F46\9@FD:?8nC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qmy@:?E %2D< u@C46 @? u656C2= {2?5 7@C w@FD:?8k^2m]” x? 2 (2== $EC66E y@FC?2= @A\65 4@\HC:EE6? 3J D64C6E2C:6D s@F8 qFC8F> Ws~xX 2?5 $4@EE %FC?6C Ww&sX[ E96 4@?46AE H2D 56D4C:365 2D 2 4@>>@?\D6?D6 H2J E@ 7C66 FA “F?56CFE:=:K65” 7656C2= 24C6286—3J “EC2?D76CD @C =62D6D”—7@C E96 4@?DECF4E:@? @7 ?6H[ 277@C523=6 9@FD:?8] xE H2D 9625=:?65 “u656C2= {2?5 r2? q6 w@>6 $H66E w@>6]”k^Am

kAm“&?56C E9:D 28C66>6?E[” E96J HC@E6[ “w&s H:== A:?A@:?E H96C6 9@FD:?8 ?665D 2C6 >@DE AC6DD:?8 2?5 8F:56 E96 AC@46DD 3J H@C<:?8 H:E9 DE2E6 2?5 =@42= =6256CD H9@ <?@H E96:C 4@>>F?:E:6D 36DE] x?E6C:@C H:== :56?E:7J =@42E:@?D E92E 42? DFAA@CE 9@>6D H9:=6 42C67F==J 4@?D:56C:?8 6?G:C@?>6?E2= :>A24E 2?5 =2?5\FD6 C6DEC:4E:@?D]”k^Am

kAm“%9:D :D?’E 2 7C66\7@C\2== E@ 3F:=5 @? 7656C2= =2?5D[” E96J D2:5[ “2=E9@F89 H6 C64@8?:K6 E92E 325\72:E9 4C:E:4D H:== =:<6=J 42== :E E92E]”k^Am

kAmrC:E:4D 92G6 :?5665 42==65 :E E92E[ A2CE=J 3642FD6 $6?2E@C |:<6 {66—2 &E29 #6AF3=:42? H9@’D @?6 @7 E96 >@DE G@42= AF3=:4\=2?5D 7@6D :? r@?8C6DD—92D DA6?E J62CD AFD9:?8 E96 D2>6 :562] {66[ ?@E23=J[ 92D D9@H? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^H6DE6C?AC:@C:E:6D]@C8^a_ad^_g^>:<6\=66D\C64@C5\D9@HD\96D\?@\277@C523=6\9@FD:?8\25G@42E6^nC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qm=:EE=6 :?E6C6DEk^2m :? 277@C523=6 9@FD:?8 H96? :E’D ?@E 4@??64E65 E@ E96 D2=6[ =62D6[ @C 8:G62H2J @7 AF3=:4 =2?5D]k^Am

kAm%96 @A\65 3J qFC8F> 2?5 %FC?6C 5:5?’E 8@ :?E@ 56E2:= 23@FE H96C6 ?6H 9@FD:?8 >:89E 36 A=2465] }@C 5:5 E96 @77:4:2= k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]9F5]8@G^D:E6D^57:=6D^!p^5@4F>6?ED^|~&q6EH66?w&s]s~x0]A57nC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qm|6>@C2?5F> @7 &?56CDE2?5:?8k^2m W|~&X 36EH66? E96 EH@ 286?4:6D[ H9:49 C6BF:C65 E92E E96 E2D< 7@C46 “>66E BF2CE6C=J E@ C6G:6H AC@8C6DD ,2?5. :56?E:7J =2?5 EC2?D76C @AA@CEF?:E:6D]” qFE y@? #23J[ E96 24E:?8 5:C64E@C @7 E96 qFC62F @7 {2?5 |2?286>6?E Wq{|X[ @776C65 2 76H >@C6 DA64:7:4D :? 2? :?E6CG:6H AF3=:D965 @? |2C49 ac[ a_ad[ 3J E96 @?=:?6 D:E6 q=@@>36C8 {2Hk6>m]k^6>m W#23J :D DE:== 24E:?8 5:C64E@C @7 E96 q{|[ A6?5:?8 $6?2E6 4@?7:C>2E:@? @7 ?@>:?66 $E6G6 !62C46]Xk^Am

kAm#23J D2:5 E96 E2D< 7@C46 925 :56?E:7:65 D6==23=6 =2?5D E92E[ 2D q=@@>36C8 A9C2D65 :E[ 2C6 “H:E9:? 2 C25:FD @7 FA E@ `_ >:=6D @7 2== 4:E:6D 2?5 E@H?D H:E9 2 A@AF=2E:@? 8C62E6C E92? d[___ A6@A=6]” %96 DE@CJ 6IA=2:?65 E92E E96 2>@F?E @7 q{| =2?5 A@E6?E:2==J :? A=2J :D D:8?:7:42?E—ead DBF2C6 >:=6D[ 2? 2C62 =2C86C E92? E96 4:EJ @7 {@D p?86=6D]k^Am

kAm$E2776CD 2E %96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ D2H E9:D 2?5 564:565 E@ >2A H92E 2 `_\>:=6 C25:FD H@F=5 =@@< =:<6—2? 677@CE E92E H2D :? AC@8C6DD =2DE |2J H96? 2 >@C6 :>>65:2E6 AC@3=6> 6>6C865] pD A2CE @7 2 3F586E C64@?4:=:2E:@? 3:== F?56C 4@?D:56C2E:@? :? E96 &]$] $6?2E6[ {66 2?5 9:D 2==:6D H6C6 324<:?8 2 AC@A@D2= E@ D6== @77 2D >F49 2D b]b >:==:@? 24C6D @7 q{| 2?5 u@C6DE $6CG:46 =2?5 7@C 56G6=@A>6?E[ H9:49 :?4=F565 FD:?8 q{| =2?5D ?62C FC32? 2C62D E@ 3F:=5 9@FD:?8]k^Am

kAm%96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ D9:7E65 :ED 2EE6?E:@? E@ E9:D[ 4C62E:?8 2? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^H:=56C?6DD]>2AD]2C48:D]4@>^2AAD^:?DE2?E^32D:4^:?56I]9E>=n2AA:5lga`hf_7_a`a5ce5f22gdcf`g224cab`_U2>AjC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qm:?E6C24E:G6 >2Ak^2m E92E H6?E G:C2=[ 96=A:?8 E@ E@F49 @77 2 7:C6DE@C>] x? =2E6 yF?6[ qFC8F> EC2G6=65 E@ $2?E2 u6 E@ 56=:G6C 2 DA6649 2E E96 2??F2= >66E:?8 @7 E96 (6DE6C? v@G6C?@CD pDD@4:2E:@?] x? 9:D C6>2C<D[ 244@C5:?8 E@ @?6 C6A@CE[ 96 “C676CC65 E@ 7656C2= @77D9@C6 2?5 =2?5 9@=5:?8D 2D ‘E96 =2C86DE 32=2?46 D966E :? E96 H@C=5]’”k^Am

kAm~FED:56 E96 4@?76C6?46 G6?F6[ a[___ A6@A=6 D9@H65 FA E@ AC@E6DEj D:>:=2C 56>@?DEC2E:@?D @44FCC65 6=D6H96C6 :? E96 &]$] x? 255:E:@? E@ 6IA64E65 AFD9324< 7C@> 6?G:C@?>6?E2= 8C@FAD[ E96 C64@?4:=:2E:@? =2?8F286 5C6H 7=2< 7C@> 9@@<\2?5\3F==6E ?@?AC@7:ED =:<6 E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D62C49=:89E?>]FD`h]=:DE\>2?286]4@>^EC24<^4=:4<nFlgb_44a475_dg236``6_bcd`b5U2>Aj:5lf_427a3`h`U2>Aj6l`c26g23337U2>AjC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qmp>6C:42? wF?E6CD 2?5 p?8=6CD p4E:@? }6EH@C<k^2m 2?5 6G6? 7C@> 2 76H 4@?D6CG2E:G6 #6AF3=:42? =68:D=2E@CD[ :?4=F5:?8 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A@=:E:4@]4@>^=:G6\FA52E6D^a_ad^_d^_f^4@?8C6DD^K:?<6\H2?ED\AF3=:4\=2?5\D2=6D\@FE\@7\C6AF3=:42?\>6823:==\__bbbaahnC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qm#J2? +:?<6k^2m[ 2 |@?E2?2 4@?8C6DD>2? H9@ D6CG65 2D x?E6C:@C $64C6E2CJ 5FC:?8 %CF>A’D 7:CDE E6C>]k^Am

kAm%96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ’D >2A 96=A65 7F6= 2== E9:Di `]gf >:==:@? A6@A=6 4=:4<65 @? :E[ 2?5 :ED C6249 H2D 6IA2?565 3J D@4:2= >65:2 D92C6D 2?5 4@G6C286 :? >@C6 E92? h__ ?6HD 2CE:4=6D] &=E:>2E6=J[ $6?2E6 #6AF3=:42?D 3=:?<65[ 2?5 E96 D6==\@77 =2?8F286 H2D DEC:AA65 7C@> 5C27E =68:D=2E:@? E92E H2D =2E6C A2DD65 2D E96 ~?6 q:8 q62FE:7F= q:== p4E]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ae^_c^`f^C6AF3=:4\9@>6D\@?\E96\C2?86\`]A?8Q 2=ElQp D4C66?D9@E @7 2 >2A E92E D9@H65 AF3=:4 =2?5D 6=:8:3=6 7@C D2=6 F?56C 2 AC@A@D2= 3J &E29 $6?2E@C |:<6 {66]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?m%96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJk^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAmp7E6C E96 9F33F3[ H92E 3642>6 @7 E96 9@FD:?8 E2D< 7@C46n %96C6 92G6?’E 366? 2?J C646?E AF3=:4 AC@?@F?46>6?ED @? E92E 7C@?E[ 3FE E96 4@?46AE 46CE2:?=J 5@6D?’E 2AA62C E@ 36 5625] ~? pAC:= f @7 E9:D J62C[ qFC8F> 2?5 #23J H6C6 :? {2D '682D 7@C 2 D6C:6D @7 6G6?ED E92E :?4=F565 }6G252’D 8@G6C?@C[ y@6 {@>32C5@[ 2 =@?8E:>6 25G@42E6 7@C E96 4@?DECF4E:@? @7 ?6H 277@C523=6 9@FD:?8 :? E96 4:EJ—2?5 7@C E96 :562 @7 3F:=5:?8 :E @? C6AFCA@D65 7656C2= =2?5]k^Am

kAm“{@>32C5@ 92D C6A62E65=J FC865 E96 7656C2= 8@G6C?>6?E E@ C6=62D6 qFC62F @7 {2?5 |2?286>6?E =2?5 :? E96 {2D '682D '2==6J E@ =@42= 8@G6C?>6?ED[ 7@C FD6 :? 277@C523=6 9@FD:?8[” 2 =@42= ?6HD C6A@CE D2:5] “x? @C56C E@ 86E =2?5[ :E >FDE 36 ‘?@>:?2E65’ 3J 2 =@42= 8@G6C?>6?E[ 2DD6DD65 2?5 E96? 2AAC@G65 367@C6 :E 42? 36 EC2?D76CC65 2?5 4@?DECF4E:@? 42? 368:?]”k^Am

kAmsFC:?8 E9:D DH:?8[ qFC8F> D2:5 “>F=E:\FD6” @7 7656C2= =2?5D D9@F=5 :?4=F56 “>:?:?8 2?5 8C2K:?8 2?5 E:>36C 2?5 9@FD:?8] xE H2D >62?E 7@C E9@D6 E9:?8D] xE’D p>6C:42’D 32=2?46 D966E 2?5 H6’G6 8@E E@ 86E E96 2AAC@AC:2E6 C6EFC? @? :E]”k^Am

kAm|62?H9:=6[ H9@6G6C :D :? 492C86 >2J 92G6 ;FDE >:DD65 2? pAC:= `d 5625=:?6 7@C C6=62D:?8 2? 2??F2= C6A@CE E92E’D C6BF:C65 3J E96 @C:8:?2= |~& 36EH66? x?E6C:@C 2?5 w&s] #ti!&q{xr C6BF6DE65 FA52E65 :?7@C>2E:@? 23@FE E96 E2D< 7@C46 7C@> s~x[ w&s[ 2?5 E96 q{|] }@?6 @7 E96D6 286?4:6D C6DA@?565]k^Am

kAmpE @FC C6BF6DE[ %96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ’D D4:6?46 E62> C646?E=J FA52E65 :ED k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^H:=56C?6DD]>2AD]2C48:D]4@>^2AAD^:?DE2?E^32D:4^:?56I]9E>=n2AA:5lgc_22af4`5fec36dha2f3fc7f34b26c`U2>AjC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qm`_\>:=6\C25:FD >2Ak^2m[ H9:49 :?4=F56D q{| =2?5 3FE 6I4=F56D AC@E64E65 2C62D =:<6 ?2E:@?2= A2C<D] x? E96 E2D< 7@C46’D |~&[ E96 3=2?<6E E6C> “7656C2= =2?5D” :D FD65[ >2<:?8 :E C62D@?23=6 E@ 2DDF>6 E92E u@C6DE $6CG:46 AC@A6CEJ H@F=5 2=D@ 36 A2CE @7 E96 >:I] %92E’D @? E96 >2A 2D H6==] %96 |~& 5@6D ?@E >6?E:@? E96 `_\>:=6 C25:FD—E9FD 72C[ #23J’D 4@>>6?ED 2C6 E96 @?=J D@FC46 7@C E92E]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ae^_c^`f^C6AF3=:4\9@>6D\@?\E96\C2?86\a]A?8Q 2=ElQp D4C66?D9@E @7 2? :?E6C24E:G6 >2A 4C62E65 7@C #ti!&q{xr 3J %96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ E92E D9@HD AF3=:4 =2?5D H:E9:? 2 E6?\>:=6 C25:FD @7 E@H?D H:E9 2 A@AF=2E:@? 8C62E6C E92? d[___]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?m%96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJk^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm~A6? E96 >2A[ 2?5 J@F’== D66 H9J }6G252’D 8@G6C?@C :D D2=:G2E:?8 23@FE E96 A@DD:3:=:E:6D :? {2D '682D—:? 6G6CJ 5:C64E:@?[ =2C86 q{| A2C46=D =:6 4=@D6 E@ E96 4:EJ =:>:ED]k^Am

kAmpD 2 42D6 DEF5J[ H6 2=D@ 49@D6 E@ K@@> :? @? sFC2?8@[ r@=@C25@[ A@AF=2E:@? a`[___[ 2 EJA:42= D>2==[ @FE5@@CDJ 4:EJ 2?5 E96 9@>6E@H? @7 |:4926= r2CC@==[ q{| 42>A2:8? 5:C64E@C 7@C %96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ] %2<6 2 =@@<[ 2?5 J@F’== D66 2 76H A:646D @7 q{| =2?5 :? E96 :>>65:2E6 G:4:?:EJ[ 2=@?8 H:E9 2 9F86 D6>:4:C4=6 @7 u@C6DE $6CG:46 =2?5 ?@CE9 @7 E@H?]k^Am

kAm~? 2 >2A =:<6 E9:D[ E96D6 2C62D =@@< =:<6 4@=@C7F= 23DEC24E:@?D[ 3FE E@ 2 =@42= =:<6 r2CC@== E96J E2<6 :? 496C:D965 DE@>A:?8 8C@F?5D E92E 2C6 2 3:8 A2CE @7 H92E >2<6 E96 4:EJ DA64:2=]k^Am

kAm“(96? J@F 5C2H E92E C25:FD 2C@F?5 E9:D 4@>>F?:EJ[” 96 D2JD[ “:E 4@?E2:?D D@>6 @7 @FC >@DE 4@G6E65 EC2:= DJDE6>D 2?5 C64C62E:@? DA@ED—A=246D H96C6 A6@A=6 E2<6 E96:C 72>:=J E@ 8@ @? 2 A:4?:4 @C 9:<6[ @C E@ E2<6 E96 5@8 @FE 27E6C H@C<]” x? sFC2?8@[ 96 D2JD[ E92E `_\>:=6 C:?8 :?4=F56D EC2:= DJDE6>D =:<6 p?:>2D |@F?E2:?[ $2:=:?8 w2H<D[ w@CD6 vF=49[ 2?5 %H:? qFEE6D] “p?5 E92E’D ;FDE H:E9:? E96 4:EJ =:>:ED]”k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ae^_c^`f^C6AF3=:4\9@>6D\@?\E96\C2?86\b]A?8Q 2=ElQr=@D6FA @7 E96 >2A 46?E6C65 @? sFC2?8@ E@ D9@H AF3=:4 =2?5D H:E9:? 2 E6?\>:=6 C25:FD @7 E96 4:EJ]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?m%96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJk^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm%C2?D76CD @7 7656C2= =2?5 :? E96 (6DE 2C6?’E F?962C5 @7[ 3FE H96? E96J 5@ 92AA6?—H96E96C E96J’C6 7@C D@>6E9:?8 =:<6 2 H2E6C AC@;64E[ 2 ?6H C@25[ @C D@>6 <:?5 @7 9@FD:?8—%96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ :D?’E 2FE@>2E:42==J @AA@D65 :7 E96J 7:== 2 4=62C AF3=:4 ?665] $F49 AC@A@D2=D 2C6 EC24<65 2?5 D4CFE:?:K65 :?E6C?2==J 3J E96 8C@FA[ H9:49 C646?E=J 6?5@CD65 2 3:== 42==65 E96 rCJDE2= #6D6CG@:C r@?G6J2?46 p4E]k^Am

kAm%9:D =68:D=2E:@? H2D 4@\DA@?D@C65 3J #6AC6D6?E2E:G6 y677 wFC5[ 2 r@=@C25@ #6AF3=:42?[ 2?5 $6?2E@C |:4926= q6??6E[ 2 s6>@4C2E] %96 8@2= :D E@ EC2?D76C[ 2E ?@ 4@DE[ cd 24C6D @7 u@C6DE $6CG:46 =2?5 E92E’D 9@>6 E@ 2 C6D6CG@:C ?62C E96 2=A:?6 E@H? @7 ~FC2J] %96 A=2? :D 7@C E96 4:EJ E@ E2<6 @G6C[ C67FC3:D9:?8 E96 C6D6CG@:C E@ 3@@DE E96 =@42= H2E6C DFAA=J]k^Am

kAmr2CC@==[ E:4<:?8 @77 E9:?8D %96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ E9:?<D E9:D =68:D=2E:@? 5@6D C:89E[ D2JD E96 3:== C6BF:C6D =@42= @77:4:2=D E@ >2:?E2:? E96 =2?5 2D AF3=:4 @A6? DA246[ AC@9:3:ED ?6H 56G6=@A>6?E @C 4@>>6C4:2= FD6[ 2?5 :?4=F56D 2 “C6G6CD:@?2CJ 4=2FD6” E92E 4@F=5 8:G6 @H?6CD9:A 324< E@ E96 7656C2= 8@G6C?>6?E :7 E96 4:EJ “72:=D E@ 4@>A=J H:E9 E96D6 4@?5:E:@?D]”k^Am

kAm%96 4@>>@? 56?@>:?2E@C 96C6[ 96 D2JD[ :D 7@==@H:?8 E96 =2H[ H@C<:?8 H:E9 =@42= 4@>>F?:E:6D 2?5 >2<:?8 2?J =2?5 EC2?D76C AC@A@D2=D EC2?DA2C6?E 2?5 4=62C H9:=6 3F:=5:?8 :? D2768F2C5D E92E 92G6 2 4=62C AF3=:4 36?67:E]k^Am

kAmpD 2 3@EE@> =:?6[ r2CC@== A@:?ED E@ 2 D92C65 AC:?4:A=6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5C:G6]8@@8=6]4@>^7:=6^5^`Bfa$\8K2v6yHvEF'Ca}tf_"bs2_sd)_\^G:6HnC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qm5@4F>6?Ek^2m 6?5@CD65 3J fd ?2E:@?2=[ DE2E6[ 2?5 =@42= AF3=:4 =2?5D @C82?:K2E:@?D 5FC:?8 E96 7656C2= 3F586E C64@?4:=:2E:@? 7:89E =2DE J62C] %96 5@4F>6?E 2C8F6D E92E “AF3=:4 =2?5 4@?G6J2?46D >FDE 36 C2C6[ EC2?DA2C6?E[ 244@F?E23=6[ 2?5 C@@E65 :? A=246\32D65 ?665D E92E D6CG6 2 4@>A6==:?8 AF3=:4 :?E6C6DE]” &?7@CEF?2E6=J[ 2D r2CC@== <?@HD[ ?@E 2== =68:D=2E@CD @C 7656C2= >2?286CD D92C6 E96D6 :562=D]k^Am

kAm~?6 6I2>A=6 :D A=2J:?8 @FE C:89E ?@H :? ~C68@?[ H96C6 #6AF3=:42? r@?8C6DD>2? r=:77 q6?EK :?EC@5F465 2 3:== E92E H@F=5 EC2?D76C d__ 24C6D @7 |@F?E w@@5 }2E:@?2= u@C6DE E@ %96 s2==6D[ 2 4:EJ @7 `e[___ @? E96 r@=F>3:2 #:G6C] %96 DE2E65 AFCA@D6 :D E@ 2==@H E96 4:EJ E@ 6IA2?5 2 C6D6CG@:C E92E’D 4CF4:2= E@ AC@G:5:?8 6?@F89 H2E6C 7@C 7FEFC6 FC32? 8C@HE9] x? y2?F2CJ[ ~C68@? !F3=:4 #25:@ E@@< 2 566A6C =@@< 2?5 >256 2 4@?G:?4:?8 42D6 E92E E96 C62= >@E:G6 :D E@ AC@G:56 H2E6C 7@C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]@A3]@C8^2CE:4=6^a_ae^_`^`d^2D\8@@8=6D\H2E6C\56>2?5D\8C@H\E96\52==6D\2:>D\E@\AF==\>@C6\7C@>\>@F?E\9@@5\7@C6DE^nC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qmv@@8=6 52E2 46?E6CDk^2m]k^Am

kAm“%96 ?@E:@? E92E E9:D H2E6C :D D@>69@H 7@C 5C:?<:?8 H2E6C 7@C C6D:56?ED[ :E’D ;FDE 2 72==24J[” y@9? s6'@6[ D6?:@C 25G:D@C 2E (2E6C(2E49 @7 ~C68@?[ E@=5 ~!#] “~3G:@FD=J[ E96 8C62E 5C:G6C @7 56>2?5 7@C H2E6C :? %96 s2==6D :D v@@8=6]”k^Am

kAm%96 3:== :D 4FCC6?E=J F?56C C6G:6H 3J E96 $6?2E6 r@>>:EE66 @? t?6C8J 2?5 }2EFC2= #6D@FC46D]k^Am

kAmx? %6I2D[ E96 &]$] u:D9 2?5 (:=5=:76 $6CG:46 92D AC@A@D65 5@:?8 2 =2?5 DH2A H:E9 $A246)—E96 4@>>6C4:2= DA246 EC2?DA@CE 4@>A2?J 7@F?565 :? a__a 3J t=@? |FD<—E92E H@F=5 92G6 25G6CD6 :>A24E @? E96 {@H6C #:@ vC2?56 '2==6J }2E:@?2= (:=5=:76 #67F86[ 2 D6C:6D @7 923:E2E EC24ED 2=@?8 E96 7:?2= `d_ >:=6D @7 E96 #:@ vC2?56 #:G6C]k^Am

kAmp44@C5:?8 E@ s676?56CD @7 (:=5=:76[ H9:49 @AA@D6D E96 DH2A[ E96 C67F86 :D 9@>6 “E@ 2E =62DE `g E9C62E6?65 2?5 6?52?86C65 DA64:6D[” :?4=F5:?8 “2== 7:G6 DA64:6D @7 D62 EFCE=6 7@F?5 :? E96 vF=7 @7 |6I:4@]”k^Am

kAm%96 AC@A@D65 6I492?86 :?G@=G6D 8:G:?8 f`a 24C6D @7 C67F86 =2?5 E@ $A246) :? 6I492?86 7@C 2 D>2==6C 2>@F?E @7 =2?5i eha 24C6D[ D@>6 @7 H9:49 H@F=5 36 8:G6? E@ 2 5:776C6?E ?2E:@?2= C67F86 ?62C3J[ {28F?2 pE2D4@D2] p44@C5:?8 E@ E96 8@G6C?>6?E’D sC27E t?G:C@?>6?E2= pDD6DD>6?E[ E96 =2?5 E2<6? 7C@> E96 {@H6C #:@ vC2?56 '2==6J C67F86 H@F=5 36 FD65 7@C “C6D:56?E:2=[ 4@>>6C4:2=[ :?5FDEC:2=[ 2?5 :?7C2DECF4EFC6 AFCA@D6D]” %92E :Di 4@?DECF4E:@?]k^Am

kAm}2E92? |2C4J[ D6?:@C 7656C2= =2?5D A@=:4J 2?2=JDE 7@C s676?56CD @7 (:=5=:76[ A@:?ED @FE E92E =2?5 6I492?86D 2C6 2==@H65 F?56C E96 =2H E92E 4C62E65 E96 ?2E:@?2= C67F86 DJDE6>i E96 }2E:@?2= (:=5=:76 #67F86 $JDE6> p5>:?:DEC2E:@? p4E[ H9:49 FD6D E96 A9C2D6 “DF:E23=6 7@C 5:DA@D:E:@?” 3FE 5@6D?’E 567:?6 :E] x? s676?56CD’ G:6H[ :E’D ?@E 2E 2== DF:E23=6 E@ EC256 2H2J =2?5 G:E2= E@ E96 962=E9 @7 E9:D C67F86[ 2?5 E96J 4@?E6?5 E92E E9:D DH2A :8?@C6D E92E C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ]k^Am

kAm“%96 C67F86 :D DECF?8 @FE 2=@?8 E96 C:G6C—:E’D 2 =@?8 4@CC:5@C[” |2C4J D2JD] “%96 AC:>2CJ >2?286>6?E 8@2= @7 E96 C67F86 :D E@ AC@E64E 2?5 C6DE@C6 923:E2E] %9:D f`a 24C6D H@F=5 4FE 2 3:8 49F?< @FE @7 E92E 4@CC:5@C[ D6G6C:?8 :E A6C>2?6?E=J]”k^Am

kAmp AF3=:4 4@>>6?E A6C:@5 @? E9:D 6I492?86 ;FDE 6?565] x7 :E’D 2AAC@G65 3J u:D9 2?5 (:=5=:76[ s676?56CD 92D E96 @AE:@? @7 AFCDF:?8 =:E:82E:@?]k^Am

kAmu:?2==J[ :? y24<D@?[ (J@>:?8[ 2 =@42= 8C@FA 42==65 E96 y24<D@? w@=6 r@>>F?:EJ w@FD:?8 %CFDE :D 9@A:?8 E@ 3F:=5 be C6?E2= F?:ED @? 2 b]`d\24C6 A2C46= E92E’D 4FCC6?E=J A2CE @7 E96 qC:586C\%6E@? }2E:@?2= u@C6DE] %9:D AC@;64E—H9:49 92D ?@ 4@??64E:@? E@ E96 w&s\s~x E2D< 7@C46—:D 2:>65 2E AC@G:5:?8 277@C523=6 C6?E2=D E@ 2 >:I @7 &]$] u@C6DE $6CG:46 DE277 2?5 AC:G2E6\D64E@C 6>A=@J66D H9@ =:G6 :? %6E@? r@F?EJ]k^Am

kAmp44@C5:?8 E@ 2 C6A@CE :? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^>@F?E2:?;@FC?2=]@C8^2\D=:AA6CJ\D=@A6\BF6DE\E@\3F:=5\277@C523=6\9@FD:?8\:?\?2E:@?2=\7@C6DE\:?\;24<D@?\HJ@>:?8\C2:D6D\2=2C>\@G6C\AF3=:4\=2?5\FD6^nC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qm|@F?E2:? y@FC?2=[k^2m 2 AF3=:4 :?E6C6DE ?@?AC@7:E[ E96 AC@A@D2= 92D 5C2H? 3@E9 =@42= DFAA@CE 2?5 @AA@D:E:@?] ~?6 2C8F>6?E 282:?DE :E :D E92E 2 AC@;64E =:<6 E9:D D9@F=5 36 56D:8?65 @?=J E@ :?4=F56 7656C2= 6>A=@J66D 2D C6?E6CD]k^Am

kAmx? E96 DF>>6C @7 a_ad[ %96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJ DF3>:EE65 uC665@> @7 x?7@C>2E:@? p4E C6BF6DED E@ =62C? >@C6 23@FE E96 y@:?E %2D< u@C46 @? u656C2= {2?5 7@C w@FD:?8] %@ @3E2:? 6G6? 2 A2CE:2= C6=62D6 @7 C64@C5D[ :ED =2HJ6CD 925 E@ 7:=6 =:E:82E:@? 282:?DE E96 s~x[ w&s[ 2?5 E96 q{| 62C=:6C E9:D J62C] %96 5@4F>6?ED C6=62D65 D@ 72C[ r2CC@== D2JD[ D9@H =:EE=6 D:8? @7 6?8286>6?E H:E9 “=@42= =6256CD @C 4@>>F?:EJ 8C@FAD” 2D C6BF:C65 3J E96 |~&]k^Am

kAm%96 5@4F>6?ED 5@ D9@H[ 2D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]AF3=:45@>2:?]>65:2^A^ECF>A\:?E6C:@C\>:<6\=66\7656C2=\=2?5\D2=6DnFE>0D@FC46lA@DE\6>2:=\E:E=6U2>AjAF3=:42E:@?0:5lc__edcdU2>AjA@DE0:5l`hca`cfb_U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?l6>2:=\A@DE\E:E=6U2>Aj:DuC66>2:=lECF6U2>AjClBf`=gU2>AjEC:65#65:C64ElECF6U2>AjFE>0>65:F>l6>2:=Qm!F3=:4 s@>2:?k^2m C6A@CED[ “E92E !C6D:56?E s@?2=5 %CF>A’D x?E6C:@C s6A2CE>6?E D92C65 C6D62C49 H:E9 E96 $6?2E6 t?6C8J 2?5 }2EFC2= #6D@FC46D r@>>:EE66[ H9:49 {66 492:CD[ 2?5 96=A65 4C27E E2=<:?8 A@:?ED E92E {66 FD65 E@ A:E49 9:D 4@?EC@G6CD:2= AC@A@D2=]”k^Am

kAm%96J 2=D@ C67=64E :?E6C6DE :? 3F:=5:?8 9@>6D :? {2D '682D] sFC:?8 2 >66E:?8 96=5 E96C6 =2DE |2J[ 2 u=@C:52\32D65 >2?F724EFC65\9@>6 3F:=56C 42==65 !{ps—H9:49 DE2?5D 7@C !6CD@?2=:K65 {FIFCJ p52AE23=6 sH6==:?8D—H2D @? 92?5 2D 2 A@DD:3=6 G6?5@C]k^Am

kAm(9:=6 25G@42E6D H2:E E@ D66 :7 E96 E2D< 7@C46 4@>6D 324< E@ =:76[ r2CC@== 2?5 @E96CD 2C6 H2E49:?8 2?5 H2:E:?8—2>@?8 @E96C E9:?8D[ 7@C E96 C6=62D6 @7 >@C6 E92? `[a__ A286D @7 C64@C5D DE:== :? E96 92?5D @7 E96 s~x]k^Am

kAm“p?J 25>:?:DEC2E:G6 @C =68:D=2E:G6 AC@A@D2= 7@C E96 FD6 @C 5:DA@D2= @7 AF3=:4 =2?5D 7@C 277@C523=6 9@FD:?8 ?665D E@ 92G6 C6BF:C6>6?ED E92E E96 =2?5 ?6G6C 7F6=D DA64F=2E:G6 56G6=@A>6?E[” 96 D2JD] “&?7@CEF?2E6=J[ E96 25>:?:DEC2E:@? D66>D E@ H2?E E@ 5C2H 4:C4=6D 2C@F?5 4:E:6D 2?5 E@H?D 2?5 AFE 2 7@C D2=6 D:8? @? 2== E96 7656C2= =2?5D :?D:56 :E] q=F?E 2AAC@2496D =:<6 E9:D 4@F=5 4@DE 4@>>F?:E:6D E96:C 72G@C:E6 EC2:=D 2?5 @A6? DA246D—2?5 >@C6 E92? =:<6=J H@?’E 255C6DD E96 4@>>F?:E:6D’ 277@C523=6 9@FD:?8 ?665D]”k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]H:=56C?6DD]@C8^nC67lC6AF3=:4]=2?5Qmk6>m%96 (:=56C?6DD $@4:6EJk^6>mk^2m k6>m4@?EC:3FE65 :?E6C24E:G6 >2AA:?8 E@ E9:D DE@CJ]k^6>mk^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]C6AF3=:4]=2?5^9@>6D\@?\E96\C2?86^Qmk6>m%9:D DE@CJk^6>mk^2m k6>mH2D AC@5F465 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]C6AF3=:4]=2?5^Qmk6>m#ti!&q{xrk^6>mk^2m k6>m2?5 C6G:6H65 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F3D]=2^"_b<=8$#_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmk6>m$E24<6Ck^6>mk^2m]k^Am