A special master hearing evidence behind tens of thousands of lawsuits over Johnson & Johnson’s Baby Powder has urged the court to reject a key plaintiff expert’s test for asbestos, undermining claims talcum powder causes ovarian cancer.
William Longo developed his test for litigation and it doesn’t produce reliable results, retired judge Freda Wolfson said in a lengthy report to the court overseeing consolidated talc litigation. Longo’s “methodology lacks nearly all of the traditional indicia of reliability,” Judge Wolfson wrote last week, recommending the court exclude his test from evidence.
kAm$9@F=5 &]$] s:DEC:4E yF586 |:4926= $9:AA 2446AE E92E C64@>>6?52E:@?[ :E H:== C6>@G6 @?6 @7 E96 >@DE :>A@CE2?E DFAA@CED 7@C >@C6 E92? eg[___ =2HDF:ED :? E96 7656C2= >F=E:5:DEC:4E =:E:82E:@?[ 3J 6I4=F5:?8 {@?8@’D E6DED FD:?8 A@=2C:K65 =:89E >:4C@D4@AJ[ @C !{|] yF586 (@=7D@? 564=:?65 E@ 5:DBF2=:7J {@?8@’D C6DF=ED 7C@> EC2?D>:DD:@? 6=64EC@? >:4C@D4@AJ W%t|X E6DED[ 3FE >F49 @7 E96 6G:56?46 DFAA@CE:?8 A=2:?E:77 4=2:>D :D 32D65 @? !{| E6DED {@?8@ 5:5 @? D2>A=6D @3E2:?65 7C@> @=5 3@EE=6D @7 E2=4F> A@H56C]k^Am
kAmy@9?D@? U2>Aj y@9?D@? H:== 4@?E:?F6 E@ AFD9 E@ 6I4=F56 2== @7 {@?8@’D E6DE:?8[ H9:49 E96 4@>A2?J D2:5 72=D6=J 4=2:>D E@ 7:?5 2D36DE@D 4@?E2>:?2E:@? :? E2=4] ~E96C A=2:?E:77 6IA6CED C6=J @? {@?8@’D 32D6 7:?5:?8 @7 2D36DE@D :? E2=4 E@ 4@?4=F56 E96 AC@5F4E 42? 42FD6 42?46C[ H92E yU2>Ajy 42==65 :? 2? 62C=:6C 4@FCE 7:=:?8 “2? kDEC@?8mk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=682=?6HD=:?6]4@>^7656C2=\4@FCED^H:==\E2=4\;FC:6D\962C\7C@>\649@\492>36C\7@C\H62<\D4:6?46^2CE:4=60_f6a53_5\hf5b\cb65\2d4a\e`hd424ag6`6]9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm649@ 492>36C 7@C H62< D4:6?46k^2mk^DEC@?8m E92E 56A6?5D >@C6 @? E96 G@=F>6 @7 C676C6?46D E92? E96 BF2=:EJ @7 E96 52E2 @C E96 D@F?5?6DD @7 E96 >6E9@5@=@8J]”k^Am
kAm{@?8@ @?46 5:D>:DD65 E96 :562 @7 2D36DE@D :? E2=4 2D 2? “FC32? =686?5” 3FE E96? DH:E4965 27E6C =2HJ6CD 9:C65 9:> :? E2=4 42D6D] w6 92D 2=D@ DH:E4965 >6E9@5D[ @?46 3C288:?8 96’D “2 %t| 8FJ[” 3FE =2E6C 492?8:?8 E@ !{|[ 2 >6E9@5 86?6C2==J FD65 7@C 3F=< E6DE:?8 7@C 2D36DE@D] yF586 (@=7D@? D2:5 E96 DH:E49 F?56C>:?65 E96 4C65:3:=:EJ @7 {@?8@’D E6DE:?8[ D2J:?8 :E H2D “56G6=@A65 2?5 2AA=:65 :? 4@??64E:@? H:E9 2D36DE@D\E2=4 =:E:82E:@?]”k^Am
kAm{@?8@ <6AE C6G:D:?8 9:D >6E9@5D 27E6C DH:E49:?8 E@ !{|[ E96 ;F586 ?@E65[ DF886DE:?8 96 925?’E 56G6=@A65 2 AC@46DD E92E H@F=5 AC@5F46 C6=:23=6 C6DF=ED] {@?8@[ 2 >2E6C:2= D4:6?E:DE 3J EC2:?:?8[ 92D >256 >:==:@?D @7 5@==2CD @G6C 9:D 42C66C AC@G:5:?8 6IA6CE E6DE:>@?J 7@C A=2:?E:77D :? 2D36DE@D =2HDF:ED]k^Am
kAmy@9?D@? U2>Aj y@9?D@? D2:5 E96 yF=J `_ C6A@CE[ 2 C6G6CD2= @7 yF586 (@=7D@?’D :?:E:2= C64@>>6?52E:@?D[ H2D “2 564:D:G6 C6;64E:@? @7 A=2:?E:77D’ =2E6DE 2EE6>AE E@ AFE =:E:82E:@?\5C:G6? 2D36DE@D E6DE:?8 367@C6 2 ;FCJ]”k^Am
kAm“p7E6C 6IE6?D:G6 3C:67:?8 2?5 2 s2F36CE 6G:56?E:2CJ 962C:?8[ E96 $A64:2= |2DE6C 4@?4=F565 E92E A=2:?E:77D 72:=65 E@ 6DE23=:D9 E92E sC] {@?8@’D !{|\49CJD@E:=6 >6E9@5@=@8J :D DF77:4:6?E=J C6=:23=6 E@ 36 25>:EE65 2E EC:2=[” D2:5 tC:< w22D[ 9625 @7 =:E:82E:@? 2E yU2>Ajy]k^Am
kAmy@9?D@? U2>Aj y@9?D@? 925 @776C65 >@C6 E92? Sh 3:==:@? :? %6I2D 32?<CFAE4J 4@FCE E@ D6EE=6 @G2C:2? 42?46C 4=2:>D[ 6G6? 2D :E >2:?E2:?D E2=4F> A@H56C 5@6D?’E 4@?E2:? 2D36DE@D 2?5 42?’E >:8C2E6 FA E96 9F>2? C6AC@5F4E:G6 EC24E E@ E96 @G2C:6D 2?JH2J] %92E A=2? H2D C6;64E65 3J 2 ;F586 27E6C E96 7:C> q62D=6J p==6? 7@F89E :E :? E96 9@A6D @7 86EE:?8 :ED 4=:6?E 9:896C A2J52JD :? @E96C 4@FCED]k^Am
kAm%92E =65 yU2>Ajy E@ 8@ @? E96 @776?D:G6 282:?DE A=2:?E:77 6IA6CED 2?5 =2HJ6CD[ DF:?8 sC] y24BF6=:?6 |@=:?6[ 2 7C6BF6?E A=2:?E:77 6IA6CE H9@ HC@E6 2 DEF5J 4=2:>:?8 bb 42?46C A2E:6?ED 925 “?@ <?@H? 2=E6C?2E:G6 6IA@DFC6” E@ 2D36DE@D @E96C E92? E2=4] xE EFC?D @FE 2E =62DE `` @7 E96 DF3;64ED 925 4=2:>65 @E96C 6IA@DFC6D :? =:E:82E:@?[ E9C66 @7 H9@> FD65 sC] |@=:?6 2D 2? 6IA6CE]k^Am
kAmq62D=6J p==6? 2=D@ 92D 366? 5:DBF2=:7:65 7C@> E96 |s{ 2?5 DE2E6 4@FCE E2=4 =:E:82E:@? :? }6H y6CD6J[ !9:=256=A9:2[ x==:?@:D 2?5 u=@C:52 7@C kDEC@?8mk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=682=?6HD=:?6]4@>^4@@<\4@F?EJ\C64@C5^362D=6J\2==6?\3@@E65\7C@>\=@@>:?8\E2=4\EC:2=\:?\49:428@^2CE:4=60b_e`b5e5\__23\c5`h\h``c\a`b66_f5662b]9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmH@C<:?8 H:E9 2 7@C>6C yU2>Ajy 2EE@C?6Jk^2mk^DEC@?8m :? H92E ;F586D 92G6 4@?4=F565 H2D 2 D6C:@FD G:@=2E:@? @7 E96 CF=6D @7 AC@76DD:@?2= 4@?5F4E]k^Am