(MADISON, WISC.) The question of which court should hear a case isn’t always as easy as it might seem – and the answer can sometimes make a difference in the potential outcome. For instance, in 2013, the government of Plaquemines Parish, Louisiana, decided to sue several oil companies for violating a 1978 state law that required a state permit for oil production along the Louisiana coast.
Some of that oil production activity dated back even further, to World War II. The oil companies, led by Chevron, fought the lawsuit in part by saying they were under a federal contract and following federal directives to boost oil production to support the war effort.
kAm%96 42D6 >256 :ED H2J E@ E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE @G6C 2 BF6DE:@? E92E H2D ?@E 23@FE E96 DF3DE2?46 @7 E96 42D6 – H96E96C E96 4@>A2?:6D 925 @C 925 ?@E G:@=2E65 E96 DE2E6 =2H – 3FE C2E96C H96E96C E96 5:DAFE6 D9@F=5 36 962C5 :? 2 {@F:D:2?2 DE2E6 4@FCE[ @C H96E96C :E D9@F=5 36 962C5 :? 7656C2= 4@FCE] ~? pAC:= `f[ a_ae[ E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE :DDF65 2 F?2?:>@FD 564:D:@? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]DFAC6>64@FCE]8@G^@A:?:@?D^adA57^ac\g`b0b6_c]A57Qm>2<:?8 :E 62D:6C 7@C 4@>A2?:6D E@ >@G6 42D6Dk^2m 7C@> DE2E6 E@ 7656C2= 4@FCED] %96 CF=:?8 :D =:<6=J E@ >2<6 :E 92C56C 7@C E96 AF3=:4 E@ D66< C65C6DD 7C@> 4@>A2?:6D E96J 36=:6G6 24E65 HC@?8=J]k^Am
k9amyFC:D5:4E:@? BF6DE:@?Dk^9am
kAm%96 BF6DE:@? @7 DE2E6 G6CDFD 7656C2= ;FC:D5:4E:@? :D 2 E649?:42= =682= @?6[ 3FE 7@C 2 D49@=2C H9@ DEF5:6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=2H]H:D4]65F^AC@7:=6D^DE6A9]E2:Qm=@42= 492==6?86D E@ BF2D:\7656C2= 24E:@?Dk^2m[ x 42? C6A@CE E92E E96 5:776C6?46 42? 36 D:8?:7:42?E]k^Am
kAmr@>>@? H:D5@> 2>@?8 2EE@C?6JD :D E92E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^A=2:?E:77>282K:?6]4@>^C646?E\:DDF6D^:E6>^6IA@D:?8\E96\>JE9\E92E\7656C2=\4@FCED\2C6\325\7@C\A=2:?E:77DQmDE2E6 4@FCED 2C6 >@C6 7C:6?5=J E@ A=2:?E:77Dk^2m E92? 7656C2= 4@FCED 2C6[ D:?46 DE2E6 EC:2= ;FC:6D 2C6 5C2H? 7C@> =@42= A@@=D[ H9:49 2C6 A@E6?E:2==J >@C6 DJ>A2E96E:4 E@ E96:C @H? 4@>>F?:E:6D] qFE :? 724E[ E96 5:DE:?4E:@? – 2?5 E96 AC@DA64E 7@C 2?J A2CE:4F=2C @FE4@>6 – :D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^A=2:?E:77>282K:?6]4@>^C646?E\:DDF6D^:E6>^6IA@D:?8\E96\>JE9\E92E\7656C2=\4@FCED\2C6\325\7@C\A=2:?E:77DQm?@E BF:E6 D@ 4=62Ck^2m 3642FD6 7656C2= ;F586D 6I6CE >@C6 4@?EC@= @G6C ;FCJ D6=64E:@? E92? DE2E6 ;F586D 5@]k^Am
kAm!=2:?E:77D’ 2EE@C?6JD >2J 2=D@ 36 >@C6 72>:=:2C H:E9 =@42= DE2E6 4@FCE CF=6D 2?5 AC@465FC6D E92? E96J 2C6 H:E9 E96 >6492?:4D @7 9@H 7656C2= 4@FCED @A6C2E6 – 2?5 D@>6 DE2E6 4@FCED >2J 36 >@C6 H6=4@>:?8 E@ A=2:?E:77D’ 4=2:>D @7 92G:?8 366? 92C>65[ 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^DE2E64@FCEC6A@CE]@C8^@FC\H@C<^2?2=JD:D\@A:?:@?^AC:>6C\DE2?5:?8\DE2E6\4@FCEDQmE96C67@C6 >@C6 =:<6=J E@ 7:?5 E92E E96J 92G6 DE2?5:?8 E@ 7:=6 2 =2HDF:Ek^2m] p?5 :? D@>6 DE2E6 4@FCED[ :E :D 92C56C 7@C 2 5676?52?E E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5:8:E2=4@>>@?D]=2H]@F]65F^72402CE:4=6D^ga^Qm86E 2 42D6 BF:4<=J 5:D>:DD65 3J 2 ;F586k^2m E92? :D EJA:42= :? 7656C2= 4@FCE]k^Am
k7:8FC6mk:>8 2=ElQp =2C86 H9:E6 3F:=5:?8 H:E9 A:==2CD @? E96 7C@?E @7 E96 A@CE:4@]Q DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^7:=6D^fbb`c_^@C:8:?2=^7:=6\a_ae_cah\df\@69Jc=];A8n:I=:3lC3\c]`]_U2>AjBlcdU2>Aj2FE@l7@C>2EU2>AjHlfc_U2>Aj7:El4=:AQ ^mk7:842AE:@?m%96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE CF=65 @? 2 =@?8\DE2?5:?8 42D6 36EH66? 2 {@F:D:2?2 A2C:D9 8@G6C?>6?E 2?5 @:= 4@>A2?:6D] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]86EEJ:>286D]4@>^56E2:=^?6HD\A9@E@^DFAC6>6\4@FCE\A@=:46\DE2?53J\2D\E96\A6@A=6\GD\E96\A@:D@?\?6HD\A9@E@^aafbbgaag`Qm%2D@D z2E@A@5:D^v6EEJ x>286Dk^2mk^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m
k9am%96 5:DAFE6 :? {@F:D:2?2k^9am
kAmx? E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]@J6K]@C8^42D6D^a_ad^ac\g`bQm!=2BF6>:?6D !2C:D9 42D6 282:?DE r96GC@?k^2m[ E96 @:= 4@>A2?:6D 2C8F65 E92E 3642FD6 D@>6 @7 E96:C 5C:==:?8 24E:G:E:6D H6C6 4@?5F4E65 2D 7656C2= 4@?EC24E@CD 5FC:?8 E96 H2C[ E96J H6C6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=2H]4@C?6==]65F^FD4@56^E6IE^ag^`ccaQm24E:?8 2D 2? 286?E @7 E96 7656C2= 8@G6C?>6?Ek^2m[ D@ E96 42D6 36=@?865 :? 7656C2= 4@FCE]k^Am
kAm!=2BF6>:?6D !2C:D9 D2:5 E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^DFAC6>6];FDE:2]4@>^42D6D^7656C2=^FD^e_g^ac\g`b^Qm4@>A2?:6D 925 D:8?:7:42?E 4@?EC@= E96>D6=G6Dk^2m @G6C 9@H E96J :?4C62D65 AC@5F4E:@? 2?5 H92E E96J 5:5 E@ AC@5F46 @:=[ 2?5 E96C67@C6 E96 5:DAFE6 H2D 23@FE E96 DE2E6 =2H’D A6C>:EE:?8 C6BF:C6>6?ED 2?5 D9@F=5 36 962C5 :? DE2E6 4@FCE]k^Am
kAm%96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE[ :? 2? @A:?:@? HC:EE6? 3J yFDE:46 r=2C6?46 %9@>2D[ D:565 H:E9 r96GC@?[ D2J:?8 E96 4@>A2?J 925 “k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]DFAC6>64@FCE]8@G^@A:?:@?D^adA57^ac\g`b0b6_c]A57QmA=2FD:3=J 2==6865 2 4=@D6 C6=2E:@?D9:Ak^2m 36EH66? :ED 492==6?865 4@?5F4E 2?5 E96 A6C7@C>2?46 @7 :ED 7656C2= 5FE:6D – ?@E 2 E6?F@FD[ C6>@E6[ @C A6C:A96C2=” 4@??64E:@?]k^Am
k9amt7764E @? 8@G6C?>6?E 4@?EC24E@CDk^9am
kAm%9:D @A:?:@? D6ED 2 AC64656?E[ H9:49 4@FCED EJA:42==J 7@==@H 7@C 7FEFC6 D:>:=2C 42D6D[ E92E 92D E96 A@E6?E:2= E@ 3C@25=J 27764E 4@CA@C2E6 3692G:@C[ 6DA64:2==J :? 4@??64E:@? H:E9 8@G6C?>6?E\C6=2E65 H@C<]k^Am
kAmu@C :?DE2?46[ E96 7656C2= 8@G6C?>6?E :D D66<:?8 AC:G2E6 4@?EC24E@CD E@ 96=A H:E9 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?AC]@C8^a_ae^_a^af^?I\D`\dfah``g^ECF>A\2?E9C@A:4\A6?E28@?\@A6?2:\2:\H62A@?D\32?Qm2CE:7:4:2= :?E6==:86?46 D6CG:46D 7@C E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 s676?D6k^2m[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?AC]@C8^a_ae^_a^ab^?I\D`\dfac__g^:7\J@F\42?\<66A\:E\E96\AC:G2E6\4@>A2?:6D\AC@7:E:?8\@77\:46Qm@A6C2E:?8 x>>:8C2E:@? 2?5 rFDE@>D t?7@C46>6?E 724:=:E:6Dk^2m 2?5 A@E6?E:2==J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]8@G6I64]4@>^>2?286>6?E^a_ae^_c^AC:G2E:K2E:@?\6=:>:?2E:@?D\4@?D@=:52E:@?D\>2;@C\C67@C>D\ECF>AD\3F586E^c`aegh^QmAC:G2E:K:?8 E96 %C2?DA@CE2E:@? $64FC:EJ p5>:?:DEC2E:@?k^2m]k^Am
kAmp?J@?6 2==68:?8 92C> 7C@> E96D6 AC24E:46D – DF49 2D :7 86?6C2E:G6 px DJDE6>D @C 2:CA@CE D4C66?:?8 AC24E:46D F?72:C=J 5:D4C:>:?2E6 282:?DE D@>6 A6@A=6[ @C E96 4@?DECF4E:@? @7 2 ?6H xrt 56E6?E:@? 46?E6C 52>286D 2 =@42= H2E6CH2J – H@F=5 =:<6=J 92G6 E@ E2<6 E96 >@C6 D:8?:7:42?E 2?5 >@C6 56>2?5:?8 DE6A @7 DF:?8 :? 7656C2= 4@FCE[ C2E96C E92? DE2E6 4@FCE[ E@ D66< 4@>A6?D2E:@? @C C65C6DD]k^Am
kAmk6>m%9:D 2CE:4=6 :D C6AF3=:D965 7C@> k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^FDnFE>0D@FC46l{66U2>AjFE>0>65:F>lC6=2E65\=:?<U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?lC6=2E65\=:?<\_U2>AjFE>04@?E6?El2CE:4=6\affccfQm%96 r@?G6CD2E:@?k^2m[ 2 ?@?AC@7:E[ :?56A6?56?E ?6HD @C82?:K2E:@? 3C:?8:?8 J@F 724ED 2?5 ECFDEH@CE9J 2?2=JD:D E@ 96=A J@F >2<6 D6?D6 @7 @FC 4@>A=6I H@C=5] xE H2D HC:EE6? 3Ji k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^AC@7:=6D^DE6A9\E2:\gbeehgnFE>0D@FC46l{66U2>AjFE>0>65:F>lC6=2E65\=:?<U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?l3J=:?6\=:?<U2>AjFE>04@?E6?El2CE:4=6\affccfQm$E6A9 %2:k^2m[ k6>mk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^:?DE:EFE:@?D^F?:G6CD:EJ\@7\H:D4@?D:?\>25:D@?\hbhnFE>0D@FC46l{66U2>AjFE>0>65:F>lC6=2E65\=:?<U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?l3J=:?6\=:?<U2>AjFE>04@?E6?El2CE:4=6\affccfQm&?:G6CD:EJ @7 (:D4@?D:?\|25:D@?k^2mk^6>mk^6>mk^Am
kAmkDEC@?8m#625 >@C6ik^DEC@?8mk^Am
kF=mk=:mk2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^ECF>AD\5@86\42>A2:8?\2446=6C2E6D\d_\J62C\EC6?5\@7\8@G6C?>6?E\AC:G2E:K2E:@?\achcbhnFE>0D@FC46l{66U2>AjFE>0>65:F>lC6=2E65\=:?<U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?lC6=2E65\=:?<_U2>AjFE>04@?E6?El2CE:4=6\affccfQm%CF>A’D s~vt 42>A2:8? 2446=6C2E6D d_‑J62C EC6?5 @7 8@G6C?>6?E AC:G2E:K2E:@?k^2mk^=:mk=:mk2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^DFAC6>6\4@FCE\4@?D:56CD\H96E96C\A@=:46\42?\FD6\3:8\E649\52E2\E@\42AEFC6\:?7@\7C@>\2==\46==A9@?6\FD6CD\:?\2\A=246\2?5\E:>6\ag`d_dnFE>0D@FC46l{66U2>AjFE>0>65:F>lC6=2E65\=:?<U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?lC6=2E65\=:?<`U2>AjFE>04@?E6?El2CE:4=6\affccfQm$FAC6>6 r@FCE 4@?D:56CD H96E96C A@=:46 42? FD6 q:8 %649 52E2 E@ 42AEFC6 :?7@ 7C@> 2== 46==A9@?6 FD6CD :? 2 A=246 2?5 E:>6k^2mk^=:mk=:mk2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^DFAC6>6\4@FCED\G@E:?8\C:89ED\24E\CF=:?8\>2<6D\:E\92C56C\E@\AC@E64E\>:?@C:EJ\G@E:?8\A@H6C\2?5\2=E6CD\E96\=2?5D42A6\@7\7FEFC6\6=64E:@?D\ag`g`fnFE>0D@FC46l{66U2>AjFE>0>65:F>lC6=2E65\=:?<U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?lC6=2E65\=:?<aU2>AjFE>04@?E6?El2CE:4=6\affccfQm$FAC6>6 r@FCE’D '@E:?8 #:89ED p4E CF=:?8 >2<6D :E 92C56C E@ AC@E64E >:?@C:EJ G@E:?8 A@H6C 2?5 2=E6CD E96 =2?5D42A6 @7 7FEFC6 6=64E:@?Dk^2mk^=:mk^F=m
kA 4=2DDlQ7:?6\AC:?EQmk6>mkDA2?m$E6A9 %2: 5@6D ?@E H@C< 7@C[ 4@?DF=E[ @H? D92C6D :? @C C646:G6 7F?5:?8 7C@> 2?J 4@>A2?J @C @C82?:K2E:@? E92E H@F=5 36?67:E 7C@> E9:D 2CE:4=6[ 2?5 92D 5:D4=@D65 ?@ C6=6G2?E 277:=:2E:@?D 36J@?5 E96:C 24256>:4 2AA@:?E>6?E]k^DA2?mk^6>mk^Am
kAmk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^4@F?E6C]E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^4@?E6?E^affccf^4@F?E]8:7n5:DEC:3FE@Cl=66Q DEJ=6lQ96:89Ei`AIjH:5E9i`AIjQ 2=ElQQ ^mk^Am
