A layer of marshmallows can turn sweet potato casserole from a simple Thanksgiving side into a table-wide debate. Marshmallow fans often call the sticky topping the best part of the dish, while skeptics find it one layer of sweetness too many and want a different finish. The argument usually hinges on whether the dish counts as a side or a dessert, and cooks have more than one answer.

kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmx? >2?J 9@FD69@=5D[ E96 72>:=J D6EE=6D E96 E@AA:?8 =@?8 367@C6 E96 5:D9 C62496D E96 E23=6[ @7E6? 3642FD6 E96 C6=2E:G6 H9@ A2DD65 5@H? E96 C64:A6 2=C625J 49@D6 @?6] vF6DED H9@ 8C6H FA H:E9 @?6 G6CD:@? 7C6BF6?E=J ?@E:46 C:89E 2H2J H96? 2?@E96C EFC?D FA] pE 2 C6=2E:G6’D 9@FD6[ 2? F?6IA64E65 E@AA:?8 42? 5C2H 8@@5\?2EFC65 4@>>6?ED 367@C6 E96 7:CDE 3:E6] w@DED H9@ 92G6 >256 E96 5:D9 7@C J62CD @7E6? 9@=5 7:C> @? E96:C G6CD:@?[ 6G6? H96? ?6H6C 4@@<D :? E96 72>:=J H@F=5 AC676C 2 492?86 2?5 D2J D@ A@=:E6=J]k^Am
k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qms6DD6CE 7@C D@>6[ 2 D:56 7@C @E96CDk^9am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmu2?D @7 E96 >2CD9>2==@H E@AA:?8 G2=F6 H92E :E 5@6D @?46 :E 3C@H?D] xE 7@C>D 2 D@7E[ DE:4<J =2J6C E92E >6=ED :?E@ E96 7:==:?8 H:E9 6249 DA@@?7F=] u@C D@>6 72>:=:6D[ E92E =@@< 2?5 E6IEFC6 3C:?8 324< 49:=59@@5 9@=:52J >62=D]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm$<6AE:4D A@:?E @FE E92E E96 G686E23=6 :D 2=C625J ?2EFC2==J DH66E] |2?J 4@@<D 2=D@ >2D9 :E H:E9 3C@H? DF82C 2?5 3FEE6C[ D@ 2 A=2:? @C 4CF?49J 7:?:D9 <66AD E96 5:D9 7C@> C625:?8 2D 56DD6CE] %6IEFC6 >2EE6CD E@ E96> E@@[ 3642FD6 2 4C:DA DEC6FD6= @C 2 D42EE6C:?8 @7 E@2DE65 ?FED 8:G6D E96 4C62>J 7:==:?8 2 4@F?E6CA@:?E]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm%96 EH@ 42>AD 2=D@ 5:D28C66 @? H96C6 E96 42DD6C@=6 36=@?8D @? E96 A=2E6] |2CD9>2==@H =@J2=:DED @7E6? EC62E :E 2D 2 D64@?5 56DD6CE 36D:56 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]DA=2D9@7E2DE6]4@>^DH66E\A@E2E@\A:6^Qm$@FE96C? DH66E A@E2E@ A:6k^2m[ 2?5 E96 DH66E?6DD ?6IE E@ D2G@CJ 5:D96D :D A2CE @7 E96 2AA62=] $<6AE:4D[ @? E96 @E96C 92?5[ H2?E :E E@ 3692G6 =:<6 2 G686E23=6 D:56[ D@ E96J 3F:=5 E96 E@AA:?8 2C@F?5 ?FED 2?5 DA:46D :?DE625 @7 42?5J]k^Am
k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qm%96 `h`f 3@@<=6E 369:?5 E96 >2CD9>2==@H E@AA:?8k^9am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm|2?J 244@F?ED EC246 E96 >2CD9>2==@H\E@AA65 G6CD:@? E@ 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^:?G6CD6]4@>^D4:6?46^42?5:65\DH66E\A@E2E@6DQ C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm`h`f C64:A6 3@@<=6Ek^2m E92E 2 >2CD9>2==@H 4@>A2?J 4@>>:DD:@?65 E@ 6?4@FC286 4@@<D E@ FD6 E96 DH66E 4@?764E:@? 2D 2? 6G6CJ52J :?8C65:6?E] |2DD AC@5F4E:@? 925 >256 >2CD9>2==@HD[ @?46 2 92?5\>256 A6??J 42?5J[ >@C6 H:56=J 2G2:=23=6] %96 3@@<=6E’D DH66E A@E2E@ C64:A6 E@AA65 E96 >2D9 H:E9 3C@H?65 >2CD9>2==@HD[ 2 4@>3:?2E:@? @7E6? 4:E65 2D E96 7:CDE AC:?E65 6I2>A=6 @7 E96 A2:C:?8] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D>:E9D@?:2?>28]4@>^D>2CE\?6HD^92AAJ\`__\3:CE952J\>2CD9>2==@H\DH66E\A@E2E@\`g_hefacd^Qmk^2m$H66E A@E2E@ 5:D96D 2=C625J 925 2 A=246 @? p>6C:42? E23=6D[ H:E9 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D>:E9D@?:2?>28]4@>^D>2CE\?6HD^92AAJ\`__\3:CE952J\>2CD9>2==@H\DH66E\A@E2E@\`g_hefacd^Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmC64:A6D :? AC:?Ek^2m 2D 62C=J 2D `fhe 2?5 2 42?5:65 J2> C64:A6 3J `ggh[ D@ E96 3@@<=6E 25565 2 E@AA:?8 :?DE625 @7 :?G6?E:?8 2 ?6H 5:D9] %96 5:D9 DE2J65 :? AC:?E[ 2?5 2 `hb_D C64:A6 3@@<=6E 7C@> 2 >2CD9>2==@H 4@>A2?J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D2G6FC]4@>^2CE:4=6^z:E496?^E92?<D8:G:?8\DH66E\A@E2E@\42DD6C@=6Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQm46=63C2E65 E96 A2:C:?8k^2m H:E9 D6G6C2= DH66E A@E2E@ C64:A6D] k^Am
k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8QmrCF?49 2?5 DA:46 36J@?5 >2CD9>2==@HDk^9am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm!642? DEC6FD6= :D 2 72>:=:2C 2=E6C?2E:G6 E@ >2CD9>2==@HD[ 2?5 4@@<D @7E6? >2<6 :E 3J >:I:?8 49@AA65 A642?D 2?5 3C@H? DF82C H:E9 4@=5 3FEE6C 2?5 2 =:EE=6 7=@FC @C C@==65 @2ED 7@C 2 4CF>3=J E6IEFC6] p AC2=:?6\DEJ=6 E@AA:?8 D<:AD E96 7=@FC 2?5 32<6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7@@55C:?<=:76]4@>^E@2DE:?8\A642?D^QmE@2DE65 A642?Dk^2m 2?5 3C@H? DF82C H:E9 3FEE6C :?E@ 2 4CF?49J[ 42C2>6=:K65 4CFDE] (2=?FED @C 4CFD965 46C62= 2=D@ 255 4CF?49 H:E9@FE E96 DE:4<:?6DD @7 >2CD9>2==@HD] %@2DE:?8 E96 ?FED :? 2 =:EE=6 3FEE6C 367@C6 E96J 8@ @? E@A 42? 8:G6 E96 7:?:D9 2 566A6C 7=2G@C]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmr@@<D H9@ H2?E 2 5:776C6?E 7=2G@C 42? 25;FDE E96 7:==:?8 :?DE625 @7 E96 E@AA:?8] ~C2?86 K6DE[ >2A=6 DJCFA[ 3@FC3@? 2?5 6IEC2 4:??2>@? 6249 3C:?8 2 5:776C6?E E2DE6[ 2?5 2 A:?49 @7 42J6??6 @C 49:A@E=6 255D 2 D2G@CJ 6586] $@>6 C64:A6D =62? D2G@CJ[ DF49 2D 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^4@@<H92EJ@F=@G6]4@>^4967\;6??D\7F==J\=@2565\DH66E\A@E2E@\42DD6C@=6^Qm7F==J =@2565 DH66E A@E2E@ 42DD6C@=6k^2m E@AA65 H:E9 4C:DAJ 324@? 2?5 D92CA 496552C[ D@ E96 42DD6C@=6 C625D =:<6 E96 @E96C D2G@CJ D:56D @? E96 A=2E6] k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E2DE6D56=:4:@FD]4@>^Qm#64:A6 56G6=@A6CDk^2m @7E6? AFE E96:C @H? EH:DE @? DH66E A@E2E@ 42DD6C@=6[ >2<:?8 :E 2 8@@5 42?G2D 7@C ?6H :562D 7C@> 7:==:?8 E@ 7:?:D9] #@2DE:?8 E96 DH66E A@E2E@6D 367@C6 >2D9:?8 E96> @7E6? 8:G6D 2 E9:4<6C[ =6DD H2E6CJ 7:==:?8 E92? 3@:=:?8[ 2?5 H9:AA:?8 E96 >2D9 H:E9 688D 8:G6D 2 D@F77=é\DEJ=6 C6DF=E] q2<:?8 E96 42DD6C@=6 :? :?5:G:5F2= C2>6<:?D 2=D@ =6ED 6249 8F6DE 92G6 E96:C @H? E@AA:?8]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmr@@<D FDF2==J 255 >2CD9>2==@HD ?62C E96 6?5 @7 32<:?8 2?5 H2E49 E96> 4=@D6=J[ 3642FD6 E96 DF82C 52C<6?D 72DE] u:?:D9:?8 E96> F?56C E96 3C@:=6C 8:G6D 566A6C 4@=@C BF:4<=J] $EC6FD6= 8@6D @? 367@C6 E96 5:D9 6?E6CD E96 @G6? 2?5 ?665D E96 7F== 32<6 E@ EFC? 4C:DA]k^Am
k9a 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\9625:?8Qmp 92=7\2?5\92=7 5:D9 =6ED 3@E9 42>AD <66A E96:C E@AA:?8k^9am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qmp D:?8=6 32<:?8 5:D9 42? 9@=5 3@E9 7:?:D96Di DAC625 DEC6FD6= @G6C @?6 92=7 367@C6 32<:?8[ E96? 255 >2CD9>2==@HD E@ E96 @E96C 92=7 ?62C E96 6?5] p55:?8 E96 >2CD9>2==@HD =2E6 =6ED E96 DEC6FD6= 92=7 32<6 7@C E96 7F== E:>6] q642FD6 4@@<D 42? A@CE:@? E96 92=G6D D6A2C2E6=J[ =67E@G6CD 42? 8@ E@ 72>:=J >6>36CD H9@ AC676C @?6 E@AA:?8]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQHA\3=@4<\A2C28C2A9Qm|2?5J HC:E6D 23@FE 7@@5[ 9@>6 2?5 E96 <:?5 @7 6G6CJ52J =:76 E92E 766=D 2?JE9:?8 3FE @C5:?2CJ] $96 92D EC2G6=65 6IE6?D:G6=J[ 2?5 E9@D6 6IA6C:6?46D 92G6 D92A65 6G6CJE9:?8[ 7C@> 4@>7@CE:?8 >62=D E@ D>2== =:76DEJ=6 FA8C256D E92E >2<6 2 3:8 5:776C6?46] *@F’== 7:?5 2== 96C 72G@C:E6 C64:A6D @G6C 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F?8CJ4@@<D<:E496?]4@>^QmwF?8CJ r@@<D z:E496?k^2m]k^Am
kAm%96 A@DE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7@@55C:?<=:76]4@>^E92?<D8:G:?8\DH66E\A@E2E@\42DD6C@=6\E@AA:?8^Qm%92?<D8:G:?8 9@DED 9@=5 7:C> @? E96:C DH66E A@E2E@ 42DD6C@=6 E@AA:?8[ ?@ >2EE6C H9@ @3;64ED k^2m 2AA62C65 7:CDE @? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7@@55C:?<=:76]4@>Qmu@@5 sC:?< {:76k^2m]k^Am