Around Lake Martin, the water heater usually lives wherever the builder found room for it: a corner of the garage, a closet beside the laundry, a utility space under the stairs of a lake cottage. Nobody gives that spot much thought until the old tank starts weeping onto the floor and someone has to decide, quickly, what goes in its place.

Besides the familiar gas and electric tanks, households in east-central Alabama can weigh heat pump water heaters, which pull warmth out of the surrounding air and move it into the water instead of making all of that heat with an electric element. What catches many homeowners off guard is that they come in two quite different shapes, each suited to a different kind of house.

Recommended for you